The Palestinian Flux: The Burnham government has created an international relations event with the imposition of sanctions against further apartheid settlements in the West Bank, in Palestine, in Zionist controlled Israel. This move, while like most things British politicians do on the global stage was symbolic (Trump approved it), it signalled a perceptible shift in the national debate around Palestinian liberation in the UK. The live streamed genocide covered over or sensationalised the work of Palestinian liberation activists in this country, some of whom have been arrested, detained, and prosecuted as terrorists–these activists, a 95 year old woman among them, supporting Palestine Action were arrested the night before Andy’s speech at the Conference–this activism has had some impact it seems to me, some perceptible shift in the discourse around the UK’s unconditional support for the Zionist state is evidenced not only in the declaration of sanctions on the colonial expansion of apartheid but in the relatively mild Parliamentary reception of the sanctions by secretary of state Ed Milliband, a Jew whose parents were both Holocaust survivors. The live streamed genocide of Palestinians, British activists for Palestinian liberation, and shifting political and economic interests of the British state created the conditions of this, the Palestinian flux. So good on you Andy and Ed, symbolic though it was, weak though it seems now and will do in a post-liberation contexts–you made a mild stand against Zionist apartheid, good on you. But you won’t say ‘genocide’ unless a court decides that, ‘we will take our lead from the courts,” says Andy.

Burnhamism is more than a Hope cliche, a Cliched hope: Is it? This blog post is partially a response to Burnham’s inaugural speech at the Labour Conference, September, 2026. Prior posts have concerned a review of GB News’s understanding of ‘Polysemy‘, Farage’s Reform Party Conference Address, and brief definition of Burnhamism.

Andy Burnham addressed the conference through the Simplicities of Use Value in discursive echoes of British utopianism from the 19th century (I am reading Raymond Williams’s The Long Revolution [1962], and I will return to this question of British utopian thought, first by considering John Ruskin’s Unto this Last (1860) and William Morris’s News from Nowhere (1890) . . . in other posts to come) . . . Andy speaks as if without prompts, without artifice, without the lectern, without a tie, his brand swimming in all the virtue-signs of a simple, authentic man from working class people-places ‘in the homely North’. The flame of working class aspiration taken away from too many families, he laments, always so sincere (but humorous as well, and quick with a smile, disarming, ‘this charming man’…)…. He recalls “the quiet patriotism my dad had, a country that fought fascism in the last century” (he doesn’t mention the Battle for Cable Street). “It’s the Britain I will fight for,” he says. He exudes an air of what I can only call a kind of anti-romantic nostalgia, as somehow appropriately expressed with some force by a ‘working class’ band from Salford, oh those Smiths–does he know the rightward, whiteward tendencies of Morrissey?–at least they didn’t play ‘How soon is Now?’ at the conference

But “I’m human, and need to be loved, just like anybody else does”–isn’t this Smithean, post-Thatcherite, queer discursive cliche, potentialised by the ‘mesmerising’ Marresque guitar riff (wasn’t he a socialist once?)–isn’t this affective oscillation between too worn out, habituated discursive cliches and the potentialising repetition of the pulse of a time when ‘England felt alive (again)’ — isn’t this the very stuff of all this ‘hope’ nonsense? Well, it can’t be dismissed so easily, clearly.

On a show they are calling “Free Speech Nation” the GB newsheads — both male, one who is the anchor and seems white slouches on a stool in an awkwardly fitted suit, but sporting a loudly coloured striped tie, the other, a brown Muslim man, well coiffed, manicured, professorial — they are talking about the polysemy of “English” which is being defined as white Anglo Saxon – Celtic, invoking “white working class lads neglected by the state” and British multiracial (the implicit subtext: loss of purity) society, but people “on the left” are denouncing this talking about what does or what should constitute “English” (who gets to call themselves ‘English’?) as racism . . .

Is it racist to talk about Englishness? Both the commentators denounced a segment of the Labour Party and the ‘far’ (how far is far here?) left that shies away from discussing the ‘white working class’ of the ethnonationalism of Englishness . . . the commentator is lamenting . . . then he starts talking about the England football team. “Would you cheer for me as a Pakistani British person if I were on the squad?” asks the brown Muslim man on GB News. “Most people would, I think.” And as if that straightforward sports analogy (football is the nation) wasn’t evidence enough, he throws in his heteropatriarchal definition of polysemy with classic transphobic panache, thereby playing the stereotype of the Muslim patriarch. “And what about the trans debate? The word male isn’t a polyseme because it doesn’t include female,” says this brown Muslim GB newshead, well enough said, then right? This brown man who should be in solidarity with the trans movement, he who presents as ambivalently right and liberal simultaneously, and also as the seemingly token Muslim-presenting man, mediator of representations or its representative, tragedy and farce at once… This commentator is, in short, confronting a certain loss of control of gender performativity, and working that out by defining polysemy as basically about two, opposed, and hierarchically organised binaries: Man / woman, English / Non-white, Free / Unfree. This is an ideological reduction of what polysemy as a concept was made to do; it puts the concept of polysemy to work for racial capitalist abstraction. But another abstraction is possible as

Race is polysemic, multiplicious in its meanings and affects, totally non-binary in its movements, its movement moving, race racing in living, unconscious, desiring, exhausted communities with their eyes still watching different gods, too many and not enough gods, and raced so lived, articulated with, sometimes expressed through the automatic fetishes of racial capitalism.

What is the legal, moral, economic status of the discourse on whiteness in this country? GB News and the Labour Party, or the Green Party (today it was reported that they’d passed, finally, the platform declaration: Zionism is Racism. Zionism is Racism . . .

In what sense is the production of white supremacy tied to the climate of fear created by a majority white country seemingly every night now, coming into “their own birthright” as it were, finally the white majority is standing up for their birthright, and goddamit everyone has to listen, because the white majority has been snubbed, discarded by multiracialism/multiculturalism, it is this white supremacist world turned into subaltern narrative of ressentiment and self-righteous vindication — not only on GB News, in the streets of seaside towns that they forgot to bomb, as Morrissey once sang, the moveable column of white supremacists, sometime wearing black facemarks, hoodies, moving as a swarm greet the migrant boats with a wall of white ressenitment. . . we have seen the images, the white column on the march . . .

And then next back on GB News they are talking about a right-wokeness, the right to dissent and protest is now being attacked, they are decrying, “very Stasi and very East German” supposedly is this Labour government through the data gathering affordances of the (Conservative era) Prevent program. This is properly Orwelling stuff, the next commentator-man is saying, we want fewer migrants, he is saying. The are attacking the Prevent program, they are laughing about irony. “I re-tweeted you.” Will someone please think of those at risk of radicalisation? GB News Top of the Pops, Britain’s Most Trusted News Channel, their relentless, repetitive marketing tells us.

Should student undergo mandatory inclusive training, right to speech restricted by contractual obligations. At Cambridge University. They make a joke about Jason Arday. “Don’t look into it, it’s tragic.” Laughter from the live audience.

The resssssentiment against the whole equity and diversity training in British management of higher education. They mock “Stop hate, UK” organisation, unconscious bias. “People aren’t racist they become racist when they read crime statistics.” Any critical opinion is reduced to a mockery of unconscious bias.

If you consider the juxtaposition of the first segment on Englishness with a brown, Muslim man who clearly dismisses the ‘far left’ — he quotes Nietzsche, poorly. He defines polysemy arbitrarily as a binary. His transphobia is transparent. And: he began his comments by remembering the famous anti-fascist victory at Cable Street. With something like ‘ironic’ nostalgia, something always glinting with the Schein of white, propertied cynicism. It’s quite a performance of whiteness as (disavowed) class domination, whiteness as ‘ethnicity’, whiteness as ‘angry’ and ‘neglected’ by the woke (their word) Labour government. Where do these representations circulate in the totality of racial, colonial, heteropatriarchal capitalist flows and metabolisms, their infrastructures and structural relations?

Part of the Cable Street Mural, East London; photo: A. Rai

As if in oblique response, that night BBC 2 played The Order. An Ingoldian genealogy of the Turner Diaries in the mode of everyday white supremacist life in which the hunting of Black people is right and duty: “Every mobster and every clansman has one thing in common, they’re trying to blame someone else.” The movie is an elaborate and epically shot cop against the racists in the American countryside kind of flick. Watch it after an exhausting bout of GB News, it’s diagram is the fire this time.

Afterwards, while re-reading Unthinking Eurocentrism (2016, 2nd ed) by Ella Shohat and Robert Stam (a book that all GB Newsheads should be required to read by insurgent decree of the people’s watchdog), I was struck with this passage that seems to me to offer some historical context to the “Englishness” of GB News/Reform Party:

“The liberal ideal of “color-blindness” which sees progress as “transcending” race, similarly, equates White racism and Black cultural nationalism as equally “raceconscious.” But Black nationalism sees integrationist rationality simply as a “particular discourse of power” used by White Europeans to justify their own privileged status.47 Indeed, some social theorists see liberalism as a constitutively exclusionary, sublimated form of Social Darwinism, in that liberal claims about equality and rights actually hide another unacknowledged set of social credentials (Whiteness, maleness, Americanness, propertiedness) that constitute the real bases of inclusion.48 It is the failure to acknowledge this jungle law “off the books” that authorizes (6) a discourse of reverse discrimination; that is, a situation in which those who have long benefited from institutional favoritism resort to a meritocratic language of individual achievement and countervictimization. This discourse goes at least as far back as the days of slavery, when a Frenchman warned that abolition ‘would ruin France, and by seeking to liberate 500,000 blacks … will have enslaved 25 million whites.'” (Shohat and Stam, 2016: 25)

Jameson is good on a few things, and one of them is polysemy, understood dialectically. But he also wrote this about seriality, which I think is partly wrong: “It is easiest to deal with the two states together, as they are in fact defined in deliberately antithetical terms. Thus in seriality, as in the now famous example of the waiting line for a city bus, ‘everyone is the same as the Others in so far as he is Other than himself’ (260). And this otherness is as spatial as it is psychological: I am not in the center of my world, which is elsewhere, in other people (all of whom f eel the same way as I do). In the group, on the contrary, each member is the center, the center is everywhere; otherness has been converted into identity. Nor, inasmuch as group-formation is first and foremost an attempt to overcome the serial situation, is it surprising to find that in the group, everyone is the same as the other, and otherness has momentarily become a kind of collective identity. But it will also be clear that this second structure is necessarily far more complex than the first one, of seriality, in which people stand in a simple exteriority to one another” (F. Jameson, Foreword to J-P Sartre’s Critique of Dialectical Reason, Vol. 1, pg. xxviii). Is the difference between series (racist habits) and group (racial belonging, e.g. Englishness) one of less or more complexity? I think not and I think he gives seriality short shrift here, but the passage is still illuminating! Seriality = the social synthesis (Sohn-Rethel) of race racing. More on this another time.

Review of GB News is a review of ‘British’ transnational fascism today.

I write ‘British transnational’ to modify its mutating political economic formation; much before the transnational donations scandal the transnational commitments and intrigues that form the Reform party was shown in all its ridiculous glory, in its global populist formation of a hyper-nationalist party funded in large part, by ‘foreign’ money (money has no home, or nation, as Marx shows us dialectically in Volume 1, only its own automatic fetish)1 … This post engages with the GB News coverage of the Reform UK Conference in Birmingham in September, 2026. I catch it in midstream, they are talking about the Nigel . . .

“He is hope for our great country, a broken country” … “only one political party can admit that Britain is broken, and that’s Reform UK.” These are the “People who believe in Nigel” (Lee Anderson).

“Can you deliver on that promise?” asks Chopper, one of the most awkward (in a ‘good’ sense) of the GB News correspondents….

Lee Anderson on air, tie tied too tight, became instantly and so irritated with Chopper’s persistent ‘questioning’ (artificial negativity if ever there was such) of the funding ‘scandal’. Who cares? We are at “The Conference” of an embattled, scandal soaked Reform party: 4000 people (they said on air), “this is a true movement, the mainstream parties are so out of touch, whether it’s the boats or . . . The UK will intercept boats and will return those people to France,” someone helpfully suggested, while waiting for the Nigel to take the stage.

The ever-at-’em Chopper: “Is that possible when it’s an EU border, not a French one? You are letting people down by acting like all the other parties. How do you respond?”

“The closer he gets to 10 Downing Street the more the establishment will go after Nigel,” says Nadeem Azawi….There is constant talk of a national emergency always tied back to the risk to the national security threat from these “boats full of migrants”. Who are these migrants?2 They are singing “Sweet Caroline” — on loop, they are playing that Football song, again, blasting Neil Diamond from all the speakers, it’s a sing along . . .

“There are millions of people who believe in us, we can’t let them down,” someone asserts. The Nigel is making plans: Jordan Bardella from France signs a document with Nigel and Reform UK–homegrown fascism is a transnational movement. But now at this Conference, suddenly “there is a danger in the air,” remarks Chopper.

Something has happened, the crowd is buzzing, there are sniffer dogs in the building, in the conference hall . . . the counter terrorism police are saying that Nigel can’t climb the stage at ‘his own Conference’. “There is a little bit of a security risk,” Chopper is saying. A banner went off like an explosion, which have alarmed the police. The stage was interferred with, at some point. Who’s been interfering with the stage? Greenpeace. It’s Greenpeace, bless them, and bless free speech in the UK.

“We’ve seen the murder of one MP, we don’t want another one,” someone else is saying. “Security alert, counter terrorism wouldn’t let me get on stage,” says Nigel. “The stage is no longer secure,” says Chopper. The stage is no longer secure.

They are not allowing Nigel Farage to give a speech “at his own Conference,” repeats Chopper. The Nigel is singing and dancing to “Come on Eileen”, milling merrily with the attendees and delegates at that Reform Conference, “like one of us,” as it were. Greenpeace have claimed responsibility.

Chopper: “There was been a serious security breach. What is concerning is that the stage behind me was interferred with by someone who was not vetted.”

Someone is introducing Farage, he had a show he had wanted to call Farage in the Garage, which became Farage Live, he is the best compaigner I have ever met, this entrepreneur is saying. “He has an uncanny ability to name key political difficulties before anyone else, mass migration, small boats, attacked net zero, beach head in Parliament, mass movement, local election, he got rid of Keir Starmer, he is the nemisis of the established party. Patriotic and he gets things done.” They play a movie. Fireworks go off on either side as the Nigel rocks up. The music is interesting, epic, news media orchestral loop? He waves, he waves.

The crowd is standing. Security alert. “I decided to come among you to sing and dance. Another year and another prime minister. We used to laugh at the Italians, not any longer. What will Andy Burnham actually do? He sounds like the most radical PM in decades. We got a screamer,” someone is being escorted out. There are loud chants from protestors, they are being shoved around and thrown out, there seems to be scuffles. Nigel is busting up laughing. “What do they say, Order, Order. Boring. Boring. Boring,” declares Farage.

“Bigger government and more taxes and more failure. A messiah without a mandate. We say enough of all the broken promises. Enough with the Uturn. A government that restores trust in the system. Britain is broken, and Britain needs Reform. We are the only people capable to do it . . .

“The ups and downs this year. We wiped out Conservatives in …. we made huge strides in Scotland and Wales. We are in control of over 30 councils.” Another protestor. “Boring! Boring! We will put the prices of Conference tickets up next year.” Dan Thomas the opposition leader in Wales is mentioned. Someone else was “Reform, before it was founded.” Another protestor shouts at the Farage.

“These are the benefits of a university education, folks. I bet you’re studying sociology, I bet you are. It’s fine, it’s fine,” says Nigel patronisingly, sarcastically. He pays tributes to Anne Winnecombe, deceased Reform activist and former MP. “When that election comes we will be ready. May the 8th, was a wake up call to the establishment. There’s been a highly coordinated campaign of attacks. A whole ecosystem supports the century old two party system. They weren’t gonna come out with a tray of gin and tonics, I tell you. Now talking of money” — Another protest, “that one went quietly, didn’t he? A little local difficulty today,” applause. Nigel speaks of a “foreign funded group of hard left activists that have targeted Reform, there has been entrapment involved,” he claims (this is about the Channel 4 expose and undercover footage of illegal ‘boasts’/promises). “Reform has broken no law, we took no money, we take compliance seriously. Why is this happening? Because they’re scared of us! That’s why it’s happening! I Let the People of Clacton decide, and they responded with an emphatic win” (he increased his majority in the by-election). Blue coat, white shirt, red and taupe patterned tie. Blue, background.

He decries Burnam, saying he’s taking us to financial ruin through socialist dogma. What’s the triple helix solution, he asks. What is that? “Reform will stop the boats within the first 100 days. On behalf of Marine Le Pen, Bardella was here. Boost NHS training, its mad that they come from all over the world, and not from Britain [to be read as racist and xenophobic and white normalising undercurrents, or articulations, or expressive serialities3 in this discourse]. I thank you Sweet Caroline. Thank you. Love you all, you’re a great lot.”

He went down very well, at the Conference at least. Interrupted on four occasions by Greenpeace activists armed with an exploding banner that unfurled over the stage. Are they sure it wasn’t Banksy trying to destroy one of his own artworks? “Nigel is Someone who looks like PM material. The party has not taken any money.” Chopper (artificial negativity in a bright suit) is at it again: “The funding scam. It’s not a good look, is it? This is a far left group in this sting operation. Women for reform, there’s also a GB News reception. He has recentered this party,” says Chopper, signing off (with a look like he might not have a job by 20:00 tonight . . .). He is still very much at GB News at the time of writing.

[The image above of Braverman is false advertising for this post, I wasn’t able to catch her speech, so I can’t write about it here.]

The Big Day at the Conference was overshadowed by the Channel Four expose, trying to campaign for overseas funds, getting around regulations, taking money from overseas clients, and grounding the Party in an imbroglio. Donations in kind, the party had their money, but what were the donations in kind, Nigel? His personal ratings are -27 (same as Starmer’s before he was dethroned), AB is in positive territory, Kemi has just gotten into positive polling territory. Zia Yusoff is weighing in. Eight thousand delegates. Someone is casually mentioning that Jordan Bardela will be the future prime minister of France. They are repeatedly returning to the MOU signed by Bardela regarding the returning of migrants to France (which is also the EU).

“There are smiles all around me,” says Yusoff. “Nigel is the last hope. I for one believe that. Was the documentary uncomfortable, it’s just a set back. I’ve been in politics just for two years, it’s been up and down…the most important the hopes and dreams of patriotic British people…there could be a criminal prosecution [there is!]. I’m not remotely surprised. Two things can be true at the same time. None of this is going to deter the Reform spirit. There’s millions across this country that support us, not enough yet. Can Reform deliver on the things that we are promising. Nigel has delivered the MOU. The government is allowing men into this country who are imperilling British women and girls. Our borders are going to mean something again, our military will guarantee a hard border.”

“Are you a racist clown?” asks Chopper regarding an accusation made against Yusoff. “I think that accusation is absurd. My tweet never mentioned race. There are more foreign born MPs in Parliament today. We now have Pakistani airports funded by the British taxpayer? I can Invoke my religion, my parents, that’s just what the detractors do. I am not willing to accept that.”

Is Zia is running to replace Nigel? asks Chopper.

“I came into politics to make Nigel PM, I think he is the only one who can do those things, and the million spirits and patriots across the country who want to stop England’s decline. Now we’re going to have a few drinks to wind down a really good day of work.”

Here’s some Guardian coverage:

“Investigations launched into polling firm at centre of Reform UK allegations
Geraldine McKelvie, The Guardian
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/sep/04/investigation-polling-firm-reform-uk-allegations

A polling firm at the centre of allegations that Reform UK breached electoral law is being investigated by two industry bodies.

JL Partners, which is run by former Conservative aides, has been accused of breaking transparency rules by failing to declare that three separate polls had been commissioned by the party.

The company is a member of the British Polling Council and the Market Research Society, who say the identity of a client commissioning a poll should be disclosed when the results enter the public domain.
Both organisations confirmed on Friday that they had launched inquiries into JL Partners. The reviews have come after Channel 4 News broadcast footage gathered by undercover reporters during a year-long investigation into Reform’s finances on Thursday night.

Investigative journalists from Verbatim, founded by the Centre for Climate Reporting, posed as a Reform donor and his American father, who paid for more than £30,000 of polling from JL Partners that generated positive headlines for the party.

Nigel Farage, the party leader, was filmed saying the polling was “amazing” and provided “bang for buck”.

In the footage, Farage appeared to welcome the suggestion of a larger donation to the party. He was told the UK-based son could be registered as the official donor, despite the money originating from his father. Farage said: “Both of you, thank you.”

Reform donations scandal: is this the final blow for Farage? — The Latest
In the UK, only those registered on the electoral roll are permitted to donate to political parties, meaning the polls and the proposed larger donation could both be classed as illegal.”

Today is 9/11. As I write, on Dewbs and Co a replacement is holding forth, “Our relationship with Israel is very important for our counter-terrorism capabilities.” “If we lose our relationship with Israel, that’s not going to make us safe.”

The normalisation of Zionist apartheid and genocide in Palestine is performative and habitual on GB News. But then the question that is repeated by the presenters, “Who shares our values?” is a question that resolves itself when we clarify what is being asked: Do you feel safer with a stronger Zionist settler colonial state or can you imagine the prefigurative nature of the refusal of the indomitable people of Palestine?

  1. We could begin a radical political economic critique of the Reform party with this concept, specifically in Marx and Adorno, of the fetish. What are the fetishes exhibited or occluded on GB News? ↩︎
  2. A quick internet search brings up these sociological tendencies tied to the ‘migrant boat crisis’ in the UK. Acc. to House of Commons, boat crossings are down 40%; last year around 33,000 people crossed an imaginary border in a very real and dangerous sea and became ‘migrants’ in the UK; for good reason does Mbembe speak of these crossings in terms of anti-Blackness and necropolitics–the majority of these people are coming from Eritrea, Sudan, Somalia, Afghanistan, and Iran. Why are people fleeing these countries? The prior questions, which should ground all conversations around race in the UK today: What is the colonial construction of a war zone and what is its ongoing relation to the racial capitalist mode of production? This is not a non-sequitur . . . ↩︎
  3. I am saying, in other words, that Nigel’s ‘let’s reform NHS training’ has a racist subtext–make all the nurses white again. On seriality and fascism, see the work of Sartre in the Critique of Dialectical Reason, Vol. 1, on the paradoxes of sense presented as series see Deleuze, Logic of Sense, revolutionary desire and serialities see Felix Guattari Lines of Flight–this footnote needs to be longer, Jairus Banaji on fascism and Hindutva and seriality in A Marxist Mosaic. ↩︎

Three clear tasks lay before the UK, according to Andy Burnham, who gave his inaugural address yesterday, setting out Manchesterism in place, and maybe even Burnhamism in person. What are these three tasks?

Give local councils control over essential utilities, like water, housing, energy, transport, the way, as mayor, Burnham did with the busses in Manchester. According to the future prime minister, the UK is in need of reindustrialisation, and his plan is to develop what he called complementary industrial clusters, citing the success at Cambridge; develop good growth funds, we are an inventive country, we will be the next new innovation nation by developing the UK’s entrepreneurial (not his word!) incubation of new technology firms who will export IP (intellectual property) to the world. And through that the UK will get better at capturing full value for innovation for UK plc. The promise to make tax payer money work harder, was loudly proclaimed. An increasingly uncertain world requires us to develop Sovereign manufacturing . . . steel, defence, energy, food, and farming will be central, and government involvement in these sectors will be crucial. Allan Milburn’s independent report on the poor academic performance for children from (white) working class communities. On GB News tonight (29 June) there was loud screaming from Martin Daubney, the Reform party anchor, and a very angry, and very confused white man, about white working class children being told they are rubbish and that they have unexamined white privilege by an out of control woke state, and so that’s why they are being underserved in Britain’s ‘racist’ education system. Burnham never once said the word ‘white’ which no doubt will incense these proto-fascists on GB News, but the mayor’s emphasis is important to situate in the long history of the relationship between the racial capitalist state and the (white) working classes in the UK.

Burnham in his soft launch from the north advocated a parity between academic vs. technical training for young people. And if workers need mental health support the government should help develop “in work support.” Kind of hard when for some working class people of colour and Black workers it is the workplace that has itself become toxic. Regardless, Burhamism = a devolution . . . for employment support. And then he made what I think will be his main plank: Repair the public housing stock . . . look to the family for the cause of the failure of the (white–again he never used that adjective, if I need to restate this) working class: build more secure council houses for the working class, was the vaunted solution. Burnham waxed nostalgic for a brief sentimental moment, remembering his upbringing in 1980s Manchester, he recalled “Working class aspirations”: a secure home and good technical education. Don’t blame the (white) working class, said Burnham, blame us. Give everyone a good home, and much else will follow. His answer includes creating high density residential spaces, support pubs because of their social benefits, develop ten year plans for the regeneration of places. Yes we are on a ten year mission to raise living standards. But there are Rising costs to life now. Give Britain some breathing space, is what Burham will attempt. People need hope, he says, recalling the history of the Rochdale Society of Equitable Pioneers who in 1844 established the cooperative movement–wondering how many of those activists were deported after 1848 with the smashing of Chartism? (Turns out none. Will have to check and Will have to check again, just for the negative dialectical twist to the offered hope). “Good growth in every postcode, and hope in (h)every heart.” The way he said it the first time, it sounded like he said, “heavy hearts”, but then he corrected himself the second time, ‘hope in every heart’.

That’s my summary, subjective no doubt, of Andy Burnham’s ‘soft launch’ speech from the new center of power in the north. So what is “Manchesterism”? William Davies, writing on “Burnham’s Political Economy” (without mentioning race or integrating racialisation into his critique of Burnhamism), puts it this way:

“The gradual reversal (or weakening, at least) of privatisation and other policies such as rent freezes are intended as popular, even populist, ways of making life more bearable for ordinary people. To put the case generously, if Truss planned to reform the supply side in favour of the rich, and Starmer did so for property developers and infrastructure investors, Burnham aims to help people who just want somewhere warm to live and a way of getting to work. This is Manchesterism: public intervention that makes the essentials of life cheaper and more reliable. As another videogenic municipal mayor, Zohran Mamdani, has shown, the pursuit of affordability at every turn can be an effective way to build a liberal-left coalition – at least among metropolitan workers. Deprivatisation aside, there is little as yet in the Burnham platform that suggests a significant move away from the political economy of Starmer and Reeves. But more radical ideas do circulate in Burnham’s networks…”

What’s of signal import in this? Race and class redux (can Labour politicians say the words race and white working class together? hmmm…). Historically minded people will remember the Moynihan report from the 60s, which tried to blame the African American family as the social unit responsible for African American children failing as school; more, that Black matriarchy and absent Black fathers undermined the family structure and thereby American society itself. In its pathologizing of Black people, specifically Black women, the report was racist through and through (just saying), and Hortense Spillers in “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe: An American Grammar Book,” as well as Omi and Winant in Racial Formation in the US write about it. But what is the relevance of the American state’s practice of racialising the African American family unto pathology to the white working class family in the UK?

This is of course a complex, multi-causal question, but one that haunts the bourgeois political economy of the UK today. There is a real tension and articulable fear (for instance in the far-right rants on GB News, and in a more muted, sort of good natured, cosmpolitan way on LBC radio) that America is taking over the UK, again. The policy differences around state intervention and the so-called ‘free’ market between Burnham and Trump, as they gain in geopolitical importance, will be important to chart in the coming months. I will update this post accordingly. Burnhamism, as are most ideologies of the Labour left, is steeped in the productivist fetishism of, precisely, labour in racial capital: the cherished belief that authentic work will authentically free the soul and the body . . . Has it yet?

The central contradiction around race and nation staged with Trump-like panache (I jest) on GB News night after night, and after every racialised ‘tragedy’, highlights the racial structures of both contemporary news media in the UK and its national political discourse. The people’s channel tells us — Patrick Christy, Alex Armstrong, Dewbs and Co, Nigel Farage [he’s been absent from GB News for some time now, but his ideas pervade each show, each episode of the crisis of racial capital in the UK], etc. — ‘we’ are all the same before the laws in this country, except for white people because of state-sanctioned multiculturalism run amok. We are before the law equal, in this drama, in front of the law, prior to the law (cf J. Derrida’s reading of Benjamin, the lecture he delivered at the Cardozo School of Law in October 1989 titled “Force of Law: The ‘Mystical Foundation of Authority'”). The ‘assumptive logic’ that (in)coheres around race on GB News nightly posits first of all that there is a ‘we’ of the nation, and it is composed of white, hardworking, productive, rights-bearing individualised and formally free citizens, council tax paying, voting members of the nation of St George, and some elect others who are allowed to stay due to the benevolence of the majority white population. This is the truism that usually doesn’t get stated explicitly on GB News. They are saying (on Dewbs and Co, 15 June, 2026) that the Labour government by imposing a ban on social media for under 16 year olds in this country is imposing a ‘police state’ (quote from Elon Musk); this is how tyranny advances, where will this go in bad hands? they are asking. This logic of the Labour led ‘police state’ is operative in these same news shows when they are relentlessly taking down state-sponsored DEI–diversity, equality, inclusion–policy in the core capitalist countries.

“Many people are enraged about what is happening to people in this country . . . ” — Dewbs (15 June, 2026, GB News live). This is white code for (a certain fragment of) white people are pissed off about immigrants, Islam, and brown and black young people taking over high streets in feral consumption riots. The nation is a tinderbox, that goes bang bang with every St George’s flag.

Are we all the same in this country? All the refugees, the migrants, the immigrants, the non-native, the undocumented, the queer diasporics with wayward lives (read Saidiya Hartman on the ongoing legacies of slavery), the Otherised travellers–well, but there ain’t no Black in the Union Jack, as Paul Gilroy’s brilliant first book reminds us, insistently. Recall the words of Hardt and Negri (Assembly, 2017: xiii): “This question [of long lasting social transformation] becomes all the more urgent as right-wing political forces rise and take power in countries throughout the world, suspending normal legal procedures in order to attack political opponents, undermining the independence of the judiciary and the press, operating extensive surveillance operations, creating an atmosphere of fear among various subordinated populations, posing notions of racial or religious purity as conditions for social belonging, threatening migrants with mass expulsion, and much more. People will protest the actions of these governments, and they are right to do so. But protest is not enough. Social movements also have to enact a lasting social transformation.” Of course, the problem with them, as with other prominent white Marxists, is they have an unshakeable (and liberal) belief that ‘we are all in it together’ for the revolution (even given their formidable class analysis); Frank Wilderson and others in the Afro-pessimism formation expose the “assumptive logic” of such contradictory beliefs: Black social death and the cooptation of other Others into the plan(e) of capitalist white supremacy give the lie to left solidarity, according to these political ontologists. Certainly a radical critique of racial capital in the UK today would move us toward a clearer understanding of ‘race, articulation, and societies structured in dominance’ (Stuart Hall’s famous essay needs re-reading, a kind of re-living today).

But these are not quite the lessons we are to take away from Afua Hirsch‘s Brit(ish): On Race, Identity and Belonging (Vintage, 2018). It’s a celebrated work of post-liberal multiculturalism, and for good reason; it’s written with wit, solid research (CLR James makes an appearance, not as a Marxist, but as a ‘historian’, as does sociologist W. E. B. Dubois), and a benevolent but also urgent intentionality toward a more complete emancipation for Black people and people of colour in the UK. The book should be taught in British schools. The question in the title of this post is a question that Hirsch answers in the negative through each of the book’s illuminating and critical anecdotes of racialised life in the UK (and beyond). She writes:

“Britain is not unique in these problems, Western European nations have all been changed by people from their former colonies, alongside the ideology of racial superiority that had those people as colonial subjects in the first place. Other societies colonised by Europeans at the expense of indigenous people, such as the US and Australia, are gradually coming to terms with the highly structured, and until recently state-perpetrated, racism delivered at the birth of their nations. But what is unique about Britain is the convoluted lengths we are willing to go to, to avoid confronting the problem. We will not name it, we avoid discussing it and, increasingly, we say we can’t see it. We want to be post-racial, without having ever admitted how racial a society we have been” (“Bodies”, pg. 108).

This third chapter of the book, “Bodies”, is an excellent one, engaging with the complex gender, sexual, and racial politics that structured the reception of Venus and Serena Williams’s astounding and historic successes (some would call it ‘domination’) in the sport of women’s tennis. I watch tennis, and have done since the age of 20 (I also like to play it, but do so rarely; I’ve been reading the Critique of Everyday Life, by Lefebvre, yeah the whole thing, little by little, watching Alcaraz vs De Minaur at the ’26 AO or Serena vs. Strycova at the 2017 AO). I have seen both Venus and Serena Williams play many matches since (alas only on ‘tv’, and now my phone), and have always been struck with how racist and heteronormative the commentators almost inevitably are (usually implicitly). Hirsch’s analysis helped me to make these connections between race and gender and sexuality more concrete through her analysis of the reception of the Williams sisters in Amerikkka (I’m borrowing from Amiri Baraka) and the UK(ip) (nuff said).

As an aside, we could ask what of the concrete and the abstract in Hirsch’s memoiresque analysis of racialised life in the UK? Are there forms of real abstraction operating in her text (cf Bhandar and Toscano, Simmel, Sohn Rethel, Finelli, O’Kane, Adorno, Marx…and Hirsch, Wilderson, Hartman, Omi and Winant have different but related conceptions of racial fetishism)? Why yes! Fetishism, racial fetishism: she’s got this great line about white fetishists who start cuming in anticipation of touching a Black person, it’s brilliant. We may return to this question of racial fetishes as real abstractions . . .

Later in the book, Hirsch writes:

“Now I realise that my struggle was Britain’s struggle. The way Britain has coped with a Manichaean past and a multicultural future has been to ignore these intractable questions of identity. A new, mixed-race generation is often hailed as evidence that race and identity are no longer relevant at all, a message that I took to mean – grappling with identity as I was – that black culture, the history and struggles of my ancestors, the battles contained within my dual heritage, can be simply wished away. It’s a very British problem. While it’s increasingly clear not everyone in Britain subscribes to the official image of Britain as a multicultural nation, with a pluralistic tradition of tolerance, it’s still part of the official British brand. Interwoven into this branding is the idea that we don’t see race, that this is a good thing, it represents the ability to transcend prejudice. But this has become part of the problem. It is denial, avoidance and obfuscation. You cannot just paint everyone in the families of the future a pleasant shade of light brown, and expect questions of identity, racial difference and histories of oppression to disappear.” (2018: 132)

Are Britain’s racial dynamics all about identity? That is the dominant political discourse of this country on both the left and the right. The 1980s and 1990s cultural studies (Hall, Gilroy, McRobbie, and others) truism that not only is identity a ‘social construct’ but that its signified (meaning) and referent (racialised bodies) are constantly being renegotiated, contestations that are shifting the terms of reference, re-assembling the racialised terms of order (C. Robinson)–this sense of political flux and racial ‘hybridity’ (Bhabha–but consider the critique of hybridity in Wilderson’s Afro-pessimism) has become passé, or lost its sense, force, and value. The discourse, practice, and concept that has reasserted its centrality in racial discourse, the mostly invisible ‘coin’ of race today in Britain (and I would venture to say in much of Europe) is ‘authenticity.’

This post considers recent Marxist (dialectical) and potentialising diagrammatics of race as and beyond ‘real abstraction’. In the chapter that I am writing for a collection on race across the disciplines, I am beginning with a consideration of the influential thesis of Bhandar and Toscano of race as a real abstraction (2015), we will then explore the conditions of possibility and the virtual and actual tendencies of some recent uptakes of their work in the context of a return to the 1970s New Reading of Marx debates on anti-semitism and the Hegelian critique of the racialised value form developed by Adorno, Hans-Georg Backhaus, Helmut Reichelt, and Moishe Postone and developed in recent edited volumes and some Historical Materialism articles such as:

Levi, N. (2024). Power, Politics, and Personification: Toward a Critique of Postone’s Theory of Antisemitism. Historical Materialism, 32(2), 163-194.

and

Egger, L. (2023). Reduced to brutish nature: On racism and the law of value. Historical Materialism, 31(3), 106-133.

and

Dimick, M. (2023). Race and reification. Historical Materialism, 31(3), 69-105.

We are, or so we believe, in conversation with a certain Black radical tradition, that tradition that negatively affirms Black social life immanent to Black social death (Hartman, Sexton, Wilderson, Moten, Spillers). … I refuse the hierarchy of racialisations that is implied by the fetishistic, indeed performative refusal of solidarity in some forms of Afro-pessimism; as a South Asian marxist (with a small axe m), I am in solidarity with Black liberation as I am in solidarity with Palestinian liberation as in a seriality without analogy and in full on affirmation of a mutual, collective, preindividual and immediating revolutionary becoming of race. Race racing without reserve and in full opacity, if not capacity. . . The Black Panthers and the Dalit Panthers were responding and organising against to two related regimes of white supremacy, one tied to Europe, the other to the Lawbook of Manu. These histories of insurgency and dispossession are not analogically related–and the critique of analogic ‘grammars’ or racial ‘calculus’ of capitalist white supremacy in the work of Hortense Spillers and in the work of Frank B. Wilderson III quite radically also articulates aspects of and resonates with an emergent anti-anti-Black politics tied to transnational solidarity movements with and for Black and Palestinian and Dalit and Indigenous and workers and queer liberations. To get a sense of this relation between the immediations of race racing and its real abstractions, I want to begin with Hortense Spillers. In her critically insurgent essay “Moving on Down the Line: Variations on the African-American Sermon” Spillers ‘concocts’ a certain analogy:

“…what the feast of the gaze is to the great churches of Europe, built in early Christian centuries with the money of the prince, the feast of hearing is to the church of the insurgent and the dispossessed, whose ‘prince’ is surrounded by “clouds and darkness . . . his pavilion . . . dark waters and thick clouds.” . . . In the church of democratic forms, attested to its bare, necessary minimum. In this church of democratic forms, attested to by a far humbler architectural display, the listening ear becomes the privileged sensual organ, as the sermon attempts to embody the Word. Between eye and ear, there is not much to choose regarding human status in the places of the Holy. We are small there. But through the Protestant sermon’s rhetoric of admonition, through the African-American’s sermon of exhortation, “I” improve; “I” “hear”/”have’ the Word, at last, in a gesture of intervention that the phsycial and psychic violence of the North American slave trade neither anticipated, nor could ward off. The African-American church, therefore, sustains a special relationship of attentiveness to the literal Word that liberates” (Spillers, 2003: 251-52).

Here we have a vibrant image of Black social life as a decolonisation of attention. Spillers attends to an attention for the benefit of an emancipation that under white supremacist liberalism is always to come–which speaks to the negative dialectics of Black social death at the heart of Afro-pessimism, even though as far as I know neither Adorno nor the New Reading of Marx formation are key interlocutors or touchstones for the discourse of Afro-pessimism. For Spillers, the production and circulation of the ‘literal Word that liberates’ in and through the collective embodiment of the potential and capacity of sound, the word spoken and repeated in their bare necessary minimum, in their lived immediacy. “Even though I have examined these texts as if they were literary documents, I have also attempted to situate my own hearing, first of all, within the imagined context of the particular setting of the church and, second, within the immediate history of the climate in which thes sermons were rendered. What one loses as a participant,” Spillers writes, “on the spot one gains after the fact, as she affirms in Bowen’s sermons a certain “history as process.” The capacity to hear must be attended to. The sermon is a spirituo-material process of African-American becoming, the race racing of African American peoples in the acts, affects, stylings, and signifying of a distinctive liberation theology. Spillers continues to expand her critical insurgency (pg. 262) in relation to the problem of community:

“If we think of ‘community’ as the elaboration of a ‘critical mass’ differentiated from others that surround it, then the African-American community in the United States becomes at once distinct within the larger field of American culture and distinct from that series of geographical moments that constitute its racial, or African, origins. This precisely segmented portion of American cultural content designates what I have identified before as a hyphenated national identity divided in the first instance both from its new situation and severed from the old one. We can either read ‘community’ as a homogeneous memory and experience, laying claim to a collective voice and rendering an apparently unified and uniform narrative, or we might think of it as a content whose time and meaning are ‘discovered’, but a meaning, in any case, that has not already been decided. In other words, ‘community’, in the latter instance, becomes potentiality ; an unfolding to be attended. One might go on to say, then, that African American community articulated in these documents becomes, at times, a systematic elaboration of a particular historical order that one makes up as she or he goes along, with whatever comes to hand and is already at hand; at other times, an invention of the dominant culture (to the extent that the violence of capitvity has been imposed on the subject). Needless to say, these processes and positionalities are simultaneous and progressive, inasmuch as ‘inner’ and ‘outer’ converge in this case on the subject. By way of this inquiry, we see more clearly that human culture is both a groping and a given. It is precisely in this paradoxical sense that ‘community’ for African-Americans has been an enablement and an accommodation” (Spillers, 2003: 257-58).

For me there are keywords in this passage that can be assembled in any future experiment for a commons of critical insurgency, one that has not already been decided (Derridean undecideability is also here somewhere in this passage, a thematic in Spillers writing perhaps): potentiality as power (here Micahel Hardt on Deleuze’s notion of essence as affect, or distributed agencements in a field of dynamical affordances resonates), potentiality as an unfolding to be attended, to be cared for, a capacity (affect) as enablement, as a capacitation (as a whitening?); accommodation (ambivalence, complicity, playing by the white rulebook, affirming Christianity and Africanness differently together); attention to an undecideable unfolding, a becoming, an unending and infinite process of race racing, immense and immeasurable but susceptible, as a structural condition of racial capital, to control and/or genociding. The call for a monstrous representation practice (Wilderson) cannot be separated from the history and ontology of Black becoming; it seems to me that Afro-pessimism presents a paradoxical affect rooted in Spillers ontological separation between flesh and body (consider S. Ahmed on Merleau Ponty in relation to this in Queer Phenomenology) to conceptual practice not only the ‘problem of the Black’ but the very form of the problem.

But does the concept of the immediations of race and its real racial abstractions–and why does no one bring out the relation of real abstraction to the concept of the abstract diagram, say of discipline in Foucault, as Deleuze has it in his book on his weirdly touching book on his dead friend–do the immediations of race racing matter to the everyday conditions of building collective solidarity to refuse, fight, raise an insurrection against fascism? Isn’t this the contradictory, affectively paradoxical (or pathetic) fantasy at the heart of One Battle After Another?

The relation between the immediations of race racing and the real abstraction of racialised populations turns on what we attend to as Spillers (and Ingold, Massumi, Manning, brown, among a growing number of political ontologists) helps us to understanding; part of this is the status of analogy in critiques of white supremacy (we must return to this problem of analogy between and of race in the work of Spillers, Hartman, Ferreira da Silva, and Wilderson). The immediations of race racing cannot be simply disentangled from the related problems of mediation and representation in political ontologies of necropolitics, that is a political, social, and environmental regime that is irreducibly anti-Black, racially hierarchised, class structured, extractive, and ecocidal. A political ontology of anti-Blackness would also implicate the RSS/BJP formation in India with its long-standing commitment to a caste-based, and cross class white supremacy (I will return to this).

Its important to remember the words of revolutionary Fred Hampton, who was murdered by the FBI: “We got to face some facts. That the masses are poor, that the masses belong to what you call the lower class, and when I talk about the masses, I’m talking about the white masses, I’m talking about the black masses, and the brown masses, and the yellow masses, too. We’ve got to face the fact that some people say you fight fire best with fire, but we say you put fire out best with water. We say you don’t fight racism with racism. We’re gonna fight racism with solidarity. We say you don’t fight capitalism with no black capitalism; you fight capitalism with socialism” (Hampton, qtd. in Olaloku-Teriba, 2018: 21).

Can we address all these issues in a succinct and synthetic way in the work(s) to come? This remains to be seen, heard, and felt.

In “The culture of abstraction” (2008), Alberto Toscano considers the work of Alfred North Whitehead who sought to counter the rule of the scientific (and  industrial) materialism of his age, and who remarked that nature “is a dull affair, soundless, scentless, colourless; merely the hurrying of material, endlessly, meaninglessly.”[1] For Toscano, Whitehead misses what would “become the lesson of Sohn-Rethel, to wit that such quantitative equivalence is “the result of the fetishized relations of exchange among men – irrespective of their intentions and ‘prior to’ the development of the kind of experimental and measuring devices that we attach to such events of abstraction as the work of Galileo. Toscano points to the work of Roberto Finelli in support, to whom we will return. He goes on to note that though “Whitehead  recognizes the solidarity between the modern economy, industry and scientific abstraction, he seems to locate the responsibility for this state of affairs in a ubiquitous mentality, rather than in ‘the thought external to and prior to the thought’, i.e. in the abstractions intrinsic to our social existence” in racial capital (a term that he did not use in the 2008 text, but one that 15 years later became familiar to Marxist audiences partly through his own work, for instance with Brenna Bhandar and editing and introducing Abolition Geography: Essays Towards Liberation (Verso, 2022), by Ruth Wilson Gilmore). Back in 2008, for Toscano, Whitehead problematically oscillates “between, on the one hand, the promotion of a new ecology of abstraction, in which theorists and philosophers might play a significant role (a proposal that could bring him into fruitful contact with Gilbert Simondon’s musings on technical culture, Gabriel Tarde’s ideas on expertise or even Adorno’s remarks on ‘culture and administration’), and, on the other, a somewhat Weberian sense of the impersonal advance of abstraction, and of the kind of aesthetic and experiential nihilism that accompanies it.”[2] Toscano goes on to critique Stengers who calls the critique of political economy intolerant, which he argues is to evade, without refuting it, “its claim that rigid, intolerant and lifeless abstractions are woven into the fabric of our social relations, and not merely a matter of historically sedimented mentalities, or narrow ecological attitudes.” This is also to evade “the Marxist contention that no amount of cultivation of new, more tolerant, more inclusive abstractions will ever be capable of replacing not just the critique, but the actual disactivation or subversion of the abstractions that actually frame and govern our social existence. Of  course, this problem of cultivation and critique, and of theory’s role as a  producer and monitor of abstractions, becomes all the more urgent in a  situation of ‘cognitive capitalism’, when abstractions themselves become the object of investment and speculation, and when procedures and meta-  procedures in turn become commodities (Cillario, 1990: 165–73). This also affects the tensions within contemporary social theory, which is at once wary of abstraction – to the extent that the latter seems to perpetrate a crime  against the complexity of a social world – and proliferates abstractions to  account for, describe and ‘perform’ a world in which the ‘material’ primacy  of information (or immateriality tout court) makes abstraction crucial to any  understanding of our social being.”[3] What are we to make of Toscano’s analysis of Whitehead’s obfuscations of abstraction, and, via Finelli and Sohn-Rethel’s treatments of ‘real abstraction’ toward a better understanding of our (who?) social being? Toscano concludes thusly:

We cannot be faithful today to his call for a revision of our modes of abstraction without investigating the role of real abstractions, abstractions which, rather than mere sports of the history of ideas, are woven into the very actions (of labour, exchange and valuation) that produce and reproduce contemporary society. Especially in an era of cognitive capitalism we cannot afford, as Whitehead sometimes did, to think that the disasters of ‘progress’ are to be chalked up to bad habits of abstraction and to the generalization of scientific materialism. In such an era, unless the sources of such real abstraction are examined and undermined, the kind of pedagogical reforms and emendations of abstraction suggested by Whitehead will remain powerless. Whitehead’s denunciations – in Science and the Modern World – of immoderate industrialism, professional- ization, and the truncation of human capacity and inventiveness for the sake of a supposed ‘rationalization’, can only gain in force and specificity from the kind of critique of real abstractions initiated by Marx and furthered by Sohn-Rethel and others. (73)

These are the passages from the co-authored article that I had wanted to integrate into a discussion of the immediations of race racing and the political theory of Afropessimism but I’m running out of time (a deadline looms). Here are the passages which some readers may find illuminating, as many authors published in the journal Historical Materialism have.

Toscano, Alberto, and Brenna Bhandar. “Race, real estate and real abstraction.” Radical Philosophy 194 (2015): 8-17:

“In passages that foreshadow his treatment of so-called primitive accumulation in the first volume of Capital, Marx depicts capitalism as the first system in which political or communal relations are no longer presupposed by property but are ‘posed’ by it. Far from being conditioned by a pre-existing community, property qua capital becomes the only real community, the one dominated by abstraction, by money. As he writes, ‘the relation of labour to capital … presupposes a process of history which dissolves the various forms in which the worker is a proprietor, or in which the proprietor works’.v He is alluding to the dissolution of the relation to the earth, in which there is ‘direct common property’vi; the dissolution of proprietorship of the instrument (in craft production); the dissolution of the means of subsistence; and the dissolution of serfdom and slavery. These are the ‘historic presuppositions’ ‘needed before the worker can be found as a free worker, as objectless, purely subjective labour capacity confronting the objective conditions of production as his not-property, as alien property, as value for-itself, as capital’.vii This process, which Marx strikingly terms that of ‘dissolution into capital’, is one in which: ‘The objective conditions of labour now confront these unbound, propertyless individuals only in the form of values, self-sufficient values’.viii ‘Private property’ is thus understood as a double movement of abstraction, one which is conditioned by historical processes of separation but which in its real subsumption of social life continues to serve as a potent agent of dissolution.” (8-9)

“Roughly, property is presented in the early Marx’s work as an agent of abstraction whose real subsumption of social life (and destruction of concrete community) serves as a kind of tragic but necessary prelude to emancipation, to the emergence of a universality antagonistic to that of capital. In the Grundrisse we can instead discern a way of thinking both the rupture represented by the emergence of capitalist property and the persistence (albeit over-determined by capitalist forms) of so- called pre-capitalist relations. This is what the Hegelian formulation – property now posing its own presuppositions – entails. (It is also, as we shall discuss below, what Stuart Hall was trying to capture in his deployment of the Althusserian notion of articulation.)” (9)

“Applying Marx’s understanding of the commodity to the study of the social unconscious of philosophy allowed one to see how the practice of exchange served as the concrete spatio-temporal basis for a thinking that could powerfully abstract from both space and time. As Sohn-Rethel writes: “Abstraction is therefore the effect of the action of men, and not of their thought. In reality, it takes place ‘behind their backs’, at the blind spot, so to speak, of human consciousness, that is there where the thinking and efforts of men are absorbed by their acts of exchange.” (9)

“What we would seem to require is a way of thinking the articulation between distinct and sometimes inde- pendent modalities of abstraction. We would need to be able to think the articulation between events and processes of abstraction/dissolution (the moments of primitive accumulation or accumulation by dispos- session); the ‘unconscious’ abstracting social practices (as grasped, for instance, in Sohn-Rethel’s account of the exchange-abstraction); the high-level logic of abstraction intrinsic to value as a social form of capi- talism; and the relatively autonomous and deliberate practices and devices of abstraction (scientific, math- ematical, linguistic, but also political and juridical) that are either articulated with real abstraction or posed by it as its ‘presuppositions’. The problem of the creation and use of racial difference within practices of accumulation and dispossession, and its link to financialized abstraction and property law, in the case under consideration, would thus require not a reduction or integration, but an articulation of differ- ent modalities of abstraction, including race itself as an abstraction. ‘Racism’, writes Ruth Wilson Gilmore, ‘is a practice of abstraction, a death-dealing displace- ment of difference into hierarchies that organize relations within and between the planet’s sovereign political territories.’ Processes of abstraction, Gilmore notes, figure humans in relation to inhuman persons in a hierarchy that produces the totalizing category of the ‘human being’. (11)

“Though it is not possible to do much justice to Hall’s insights here, we can note that his return to Marx’s dialectic of the abstract and the concrete via Althusser’s theory of overdetermination was aimed at generating a Marxist theory capable of truly think- ing difference. Against an ultra-Hegelian reading of Marx that would view his mature work through the lens of the self-movement of capital’s categories, Hall stressed that Marx’s were concepts ‘which differentiate in the very moment that they reveal hidden connec- tions’; though capitalism ‘tends to reproduce itself in expanded form as if it were a self-equilibrating and self-sustaining system’, it constantly relies on precarious social and political mediations, including racisms themselves, none of which are guaranteed by an ineluctable logic. Though Hall, unlike many of his peers, does not jettison the notion of totality, he repeatedly asserts that capitalist social formations 12 are complexly structured differentiated totalities, unities that require differentiation, in which, to use Neil Smith’s formulation, the production of sameness or equivalence is always accompanied by a production of difference.” (12)

“Applied to the problem of race in capitalism, Althusser’s concepts of articulation, overdetermina- tion, and of societies structured-in-dominance, per- mitted Hall, by his own account, to undermine the teleological reductivism and economism of a certain Marxism – which would see race inevitably dissolved by class contradiction – as well as culturalist or eth- nocentric accounts which treated race and racism as purely autonomous variables.35 Both of these posi- tions elide the historical specificity, which is also to say the political cognizability, of social formations in which race plays a structuring role.” (13)

[Hall, Policing the Crisis:] “… the structures through which black labour is re- produced … are not simply ‘coloured’ by race: they work through race. The relations of capitalism can be thought of as articulating classes in distinct ways at each of the levels of instances of the social formation – economic, political, ideological. These levels are the “effects” of the structures of modern capitalist production, with the necessary displacement of relative autonomy operating between them.” (13)

“Here we can attempt to identify the ways in which a racial anthropology of the human is smuggled into the ontological grounding of the possessive indi- vidual. The primary place of interiority in the con- ceptualization of this subject – one version of Spivak’s ‘transparent “I”’ – sets the scene for an analytic of raciality that emerges in the nineteenth century.” (15)

“Ownership, for black people in the USA, for indigenous people throughout North America, and for working-class immigrants, has always been refracted through the value of life itself, not reducible down to the category or reality of labour, be it free or unfree. If freedom was and remains bound to a debt that can never, it seems, be fully paid off, it seems that justice might require a disarticulation of the fetishes produced by racial and propertied abstractions, a de-propertization of the thinking of racial difference and of the legal form itself.” (16)


[1] Alfred North Whitehead, Science and the Modern World (Free Press, 1967)  54; qtd. in Alberto Toscano, “The culture of abstraction.” Theory, Culture & Society 25, no. 4 (2008): 57-75, 72.

[2] Toscano, “Abstraction,” 72.

[3] Toscano, “Abstraction,” 72-73.

We will have danced through a series of seminars on what I won’t have called “Revolutionary Speculative Fiction”, in which the sleep of western reason gives birth to monsters composed of technoperceptual assemblages that strike the senses with the full force of monstrosity. What, first, do we mean here by speculative (linked to fabulation and the powers of the false–cf Deleuze)? And what of Utopian Science Fiction? In which senses is science fiction as a kind of speculative fiction an extended discourse on the monster, monstrous utopias, affects, and ontologies, and a discursive practice of monstrosity? But then again, maybe always to an extent (the nth degree?) all ‘definitions serve to be destroyed’? (I will return to Isadora Neves Marques’ e-flux article below)

With the publication and reception of late comrade Marina Vishmidt’s work on speculation as a mode of production (to which we will return in a later post) the concept of speculation has received a new burst of political scrutiny. When we dream together in a utopian, (non)prefigurative vein, what is it we are doing after all other than in a certain sense slipping out from time’s hinged joint, becoming untimely, acting counter to our time, and let us hope dreaming for the benefit of a time to come, of a ‘to the nth power’ affirmation of a multiplicity of indigenous knowledges that can be made to cannibalise the western episteme, as Derrida, Deleuze, Viveiros de Castro, Strathern, Ingold, Stengers suggest, to eat the master from the inside, through an immanent, ad hominen critique of the coloniality of capitalist power — the inveterate white mythologies in the service of profit for profit’s sake — at work in all the disciplines associated with our anthropocene–and in all academic pieties to a prefigurative politics emerging in a speculating temporality (without going into an elaborate etymologism-detournement of this word with links to the specular/um (Irigiray’s Other woman), spectacle (Debord, Wark), speculative philosophy as Hegel’s master-slave becomes Levi-Strauss’ kinship, as the concept of kinship is. . . itself . . . cannibalised immanently . . . as Viveiros de Castro has shown us how to do with French philosophy and French anthropology of Amerindian peoples . . . but does he–despite his at times hilarious and at times sharply polemical and at times astoundingly inventive discourse–render ‘Amerindian thought’ yet another anthropological fetish-artefact?).

But let’s return to the Speculative in Speculative Fiction. Speculation is a kind of experimentation with the power of abstraction, to affirm the capacity of abstraction to the nth power, which if we subtract the phenomenological (im)pieties of the flesh that can sometime surround speculative philosophy, miring it in a supposed science of the consciousness of sensual experience, can maybe leave us with a smooth spacetime of pure potentiality of abstraction? As an aside, we note that the role potentiality, or the virtual plays today in for instance business and management discourses of ‘oragnising’ and ‘organisation’ in process-based models of organisational behaviour or strategy and the new new institutionalism–Chia, Weick, Sutcliffe, Herne, but also the neoliberals that Foucault genealogises in his late 70’s lectures–they too had, if only in an Aristotelian sort of way at times, a conception of the virtual in economic rationality. But we are not here to speculate on potentiality or the virtual, we are writing about the practice of speculation in speculative fiction. I am reading Colson Whitehead’s Zone One: A Novel. The narrative voice, I must say irritated me a bit at the outset, but then I got a different sense of their ‘perspective’ as I got further on; but the speculation in the novel is not about science or technology–so far there is nothing particularly magical or remarkable about the almost probabilistic post apocalyptic zombie world. I will report back as I have come to be intrigued by becoming a ghostly companion to a civilian battalion of zombie killers liberating the toxic grid that is Manhattan. . . .

Speaking of liberation from toxic grids: The Blaft Book of Anti-Caste SF is excellent, and I’m looking forward to engaging with the speculative stories in classroom discussions.

But as another aside, or better, fold … on speculation … what happens when speculation becomes embodied dehabituation? Manning and Massumi help us think this other heading of speculation:

“The habit of entering into a process brings with it the promise that a process engaging with the same conditions twice can generate an event that looks like the event that it generated the first time. But what Brian is saying is that if you take this process seriously, and attend to how it evolves in each of its phases, you will find that no event can be mapped in advance. The event takes us with it and the outcome is always experienced in retrospect: ah! that’s what it was! But instead of saying ‘that’s what it was!’ we have the habit of taking the past and imposing it on the future, quietly exclaiming ‘that’s what it will be!’ Immediation tries to challenge that habit. What we have found in our collective SenseLab [I’ve been; they’re great] network as we work through the relationship between philosophy, art and activism is that techniques have to be generated in the event, each occasion anew, because if they are not, they simply don’t work. That’s the pragmatic side or as we call it the speculative pragmatic side. The event generates its own forms of speculation and forms of pragmatism, and you have to be in the event to compose with them. This is a relational task at the level of the field itself. If you think of yourself as the subject of the event, you’ll fail simply because you will have taken yourself out of all of those complex relational tendencies of the event to generate its own potential. What is at stake here is understanding not the agency of the subject, but the agencement of the event in its speculatively pragmatic unfolding. This is a word that is impossible to translate. The best that anyone’s come up with is ‘assemblage’, but that’s misleading. Agencement connotes a doing doing itself. You have to understand the event itself as agency-ing.” (Erin Manning in Conversation with Massumi, in the Politics of Affect, pg. 157, emphasis added)

We will return to the politics of im/mediation and what decolonial, Black radical, postcolonial, anti-imperialist, and revolutionary Marxist and anarchist refusals of im/mediation dialectics can offer radical politics in situations in which ‘techniques have to be generated in the event.’ What should be composed in the speculative as phase shifting beyond the unending experimentations with the immediating affects of the untimely is I believe a mode of revolutionary becoming of a people; a people to come will have displaced the reifications and im/mediations of racial capital with a kind of people’s ‘science’ (with a little minority-becoming ‘s’), a jugaad science, a hacking ecology of social reproduction and economic production…

… or perhaps less of a displacement than an enfolding and entanglement of scientific institutions (organised force of norms and scripts for behaviour) with materio-spiritual processes of speculating on timespaces yet to come, monstrous speculations, monstrous fabulations. Speculative fiction undoes the narrative-myth-making form of representation tied to the realist novel of development, the bildingroman. But then why do we still need the word ‘fiction’ in science fiction?

Well, yes, then, to speculate as a mode of prefigurative realism, a superior transcendental empiricism for a revolutionary becoming of the future. It will not have been branded, yet, yet, et. As a techno-pedagogical mode of the practice of emancipation, revolutionary speculating in fiction, dance, curation, writing, creation, continuing, caring, repairing, resisting, and loving in the face of the grinding value form of colonial, caste, racial capitalism — .

Is science fiction a ‘people’s science’? Problematising ‘science’ in speculative/science fiction, Marques writes —

“To dismantle preconceived ideas about science fiction, and consequently about both science and fiction, Dillon breaks down the distinction between science, magic, and storytelling. She describes her process as “taking the fiction out of science fiction.” What does this mean? Let’s try the reverse: it means taking the “science” in science fiction not merely as a noun adjunct, as in fiction about science, but more seriously as stories that fundamentally reimagine what science is.”

Agreed. Drawing on Viveiros de Castro’s perspectivism and multi-naturalism, Marques argues that stories that are seen as fantastical tales—and are thereby ‘relegated to the minor genres of paranormal narratives and ghost stories’—for those acquainted with the cosmology of indigenous lifeworlds “it is reality pure and simple. Similarly, it is for this reason that, as I’ve insisted elsewhere—against the grain of most film critics—the films of Thai director Apichatpong Weerasethakul are not surrealist or fantastical. Rather, they offer a sociology of humans, ghosts, spirits, and animal-people—a realism closer to documentary. Apichatpong’s films, like Haig-Brown’s, are not science fiction, or fiction, at all, but scientific tales” (Marques). She continues to note the revolutionary or escapist binary in science fiction; drawing on the critical and affirmative resources of Dillon’s Indigenous Futurism (cf Dillon, G.L., 2016. Introduction: Indigenous futurisms, Bimaashi Biidaas mose, flying and walking towards you. Extrapolation, 57(1-2), pp.1-6) she considers the nonlinearities involved in science fiction not only as an artistic genre representative of nineteenth-century colonial imperialism (Rieder, Colonialism and the Emergence of Science Fiction, Wesleyan University Press, 2008) but in a historical twist that we should see “science fiction was both an expression and an affirmation—a naturalization—of a particular cosmology, a cosmology that attributed to technology the role of dominion over the environment, subsuming all relations to the necessity of extractivism, both human and environmental, by modern imperialisms, whether market capitalist or planned socialist. Science fiction is not a straightforward tool for reflecting the present, much less for predicting the future. Rather, it is a genre that arose from a specific understanding of modernity’s nature-culture divide. And yet, science fiction has also, always, strived to escape or corrupt this divide—hence its revolutionary, or its pure-and-simple escapist, appeal.” Marques concludes thus:

“Counterintuitively, then, science fiction might be more about nature than technology—a reflection on the expectations that constitute what is deemed natural and how this naturalization (of bodies, of ecosystems, of planets) might be speculatively disturbed. The multipolarity of science is the fiction of contemporary science fiction. And this is why I, as a reader and a fan, continue to see it as so speculative and future-oriented. Utopian even. On the matter of definitions then, better to follow the advice of the old, renowned science fiction critic Darko Suvin and say that science fiction does not begin anywhere as such, “for its ‘pre-history’ is one of fundamental impurity.” Let it continue forever impure.”

Here’s to the revolutionary impurity of speculative fiction!

The seminar series aims to synthesise revolutionary praxis, peoples’s sciences and cosmologies, and nomadic and jugaad speculations on the terrain of morphogenesis in different kinds of fiction. To date, the series is called “Revolutionary Speculative Fiction” in acknowledgement of the grimly utopic, negative dialectical, Ballardian dystopias found in the oeuvre of Frederic Jameson. The illuminating and consistent engagement throughout his work with the Frankfurt School, Adorno in particular, and of the dual problem of science fiction as genre and utopia — all through the political telos of the overthrow of racial capital (not his term!). I am just finishing re-reading Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism, after not having read it for over twenty years. I admit to being quite rusty now with the old debates and controversies that seem to animate some of the pages of that book–De Man, in particular, the Nazi collaborating nephew of a famous European socialist, Derrida’s deconstructive dervishes, the charge of ‘linguisticism’ (again not Jameson’s term). But for me what is of lasting significance in and throughout Jameson’s work is this unrelenting marxist (with a small m?) speculation on the conditions of possibility of utopic thought and practice. I feel my insistence on the politically prefigurative potential of revolutionary becoming (cf Rai 2019) to be in resonance with Jameson’s speculations on utopia. But let’s not get behind ourselves, let us with a sidelong nod to Derrida and Butler stay present and intentional: we are speaking here of Jameson’s repurposing of Marxism for a science fiction criticism of the revolutionary imaginary under late capitalism. Let’s recall some important passages from the Postmodernism text(s).

“The initial approach to this particular “great transformation” — the displacement of time, the spatialization of the temporal — often registers its novelties by way of a sense of loss. [ASR: This sense of loss, this affect of loss without recourse or recuperation, inhabits the different genres of sceience fiction; Jameson suggests that this sense is a postmodern mode of totalising.] Indeed, it seems just possible that the pathos of entropy in Ballard may be just that: the affect released by the minute, and not unenthusiastic, exploration of this whole new world of spatiality, and the sharp pang of the death of the modern that accompanies it. At any rate, from this nostalgic and regressive perspective — that of the older modern and its temporalities — what is mourned is the memory of deep memory; what is enacted is a nostalgia for nostalgia, for the grand older extinct questions of origin and telos, of deep time and the Freudian Unconscious (dispatched by Foucault at one blow in the History of Sexuality), for the dialectic also, as well as all the monumental forms left high and dry by the ebb tide of the modern moment, forms whose Absolutes are no longer audible to us, illegible hieroglyphs of the demiurgic within the technocratic world. We need a detour through the modern, then, in order to grasp what is historically original in the postmodern and its spatialisms. Indeed, such a history lesson is the best cure for nostalgic pathos, minimally teaching us, by way of Necessity, that the way back to the modern is sealed for good. Presupposed in what follows, of course, is a correlation between the transition from the modern to the postmodern, and that economic or systemic transformation of an older monopoly capitalism (the so-called moment of imperialism) into its new multinational and hightech mutation. Increasingly spatial features of a new type can be derived from such economic accounts, but any concrete account of the new spatial aesthetic and its existential life world demands some intermediary steps, or what the dialectic used to call mediations.” (Jameson, Postmodernism)

Why did the dialectic used to call it ‘mediations’, these intermediary steps? Is indeed the dialectic and its mediations always already dead in Jameson, or rather is the dialectic always already entombed, reified in a European will to death-as-self/other-mastery, its white authenticity forever disavowed (Heidegger, Adorno, Derrida, Foucault, Jameson, Fisher)? What are the dialectic’s strange adventures in the intergalactic smashing of matter and anti-matter that is staged in Jameson’s utopic science fiction(s), and which are his corrective mythologies, tied to a story he maybe wrongly attributed to Marx, and were instead another kind of collective enunciation (Erin Manning marks that for Fred Moten writing is a collective act)? A universal army for the production of new theoretical discourse within and against conceptual reification? Remember that for Jameson, Adorno indexes the persistence of the (negative) dialectic.

When does Marxism become Science Fiction in Jameson? It’s about temporality in a historically specific mode of production, of course! History is what hurts, he had written long ago. He writes: “The future itself — Dick’s 1997 — is not, however, centrally significant as a representation or an anticipation; it is the narrative means to a very different end, namely the brutal transformation of a realistic representation of the present, of Eisenhower America and the 1950s small town, into a memory and a reconstruction. Reification is here indeed built into the novel itself and, as it were, defused and recuperated as a form of praxis: the fifties is a thing, but a thing that we can build, just as the science fiction writer builds his own small-scale model. At that point, then, reification ceases to be a baleful and alienating process, a noxious side-effect of our mode of production, if not, indeed, its fundamental dynamic, and is rather transferred to the side of human energies and human possibilities. (The reappropriation has, of course, a good deal to do with the specificity of Dick’s own themes and ideology — in particular, the nostalgia about the past and the “petit bourgeois” valorization of small craftsmanship, as well as small business and collecting.)” (Jameson, Postmodernism) This is a lovely passage on Dick; it brings out a bit what Jameson at this point in his thinking understands by the term representation. Jamesonian totality is what kind of multiplicity?

Future anterior: “One would want, in short, to stress the conditions of possibility of such a form — and of its emergence and eclipse — less in the existential experience of history of people at this or that historical moment than rather in the very structure of their socioeconomic system, in its relative opacity or transparency, and the access its mechanisms provide to some greater cognitive as well as existential contact with the thing itself. This is the context in which it seems interesting to explore the hypothesis that science fiction as a genre entertains a dialectical and structural relationship with the historical novel — a relationship of kinship and inversion all at once, of opposition and homology (just as comedy and tragedy have often been supposed to do, or lyric and epic, or satire and Utopia, as Robert C. Elliott analyzed them). But time itself plays a crucial role in this generic opposition, which is also something of an evolutionary compensation. For if the historical novel “corresponded” to the emergence of historicity, of a sense of history in its strong modern post-eighteenth-century sense, science fiction equally corresponds to the waning or the blockage of that historicity, and, particularly in our own time (in the postmodern era), to its crisis and paralysis, its enfeeblement and repression. Only by means of a violent formal and narrative dislocation could a narrative apparatus come into being capable of restoring life and feeling to this only intermittently functioning organ that is our capacity to organize and live time historically. Nor should it be thought overhastily that the two forms are symmetrical on the grounds that the historical novel stages the past and science fiction the future…. Historicity is, in fact, neither a representation of the past nor a representation of the future (although its various forms use such representations): it can first and foremost be defined as a perception of the present as history; that is, as a relationship to the present which somehow defamiliarizes it and allows us that distance from immediacy which is at length characterized as a historical perspective. It is appropriate, in other words, also to insist on the historicality of the operation itself, which is our way of conceiving of historicity in this particular society and mode of production; appropriate also to observe that what is at stake is essentially a process of reification whereby we draw back from our immersion in the here and now (not yet identified as a “present”) and grasp it as a kind of thing — not merely a “present” but a present that can be dated and called the eighties or the fifties. Our presupposition has been that today this is more difficult to achieve than at the time of Sir Walter Scott, when a contemplation of the past seemed able to renew our sense of our own reading present as the sequel, if not particularly the culmination, of that genetic series. Time Out of Joint, however, offers a very different machine for producing historicity than Sir Walter Scott’s apparatus: what one might in the strong sense call a trope of the future anterior -the estrangement and renewal as history of our own reading present, the fifties, by way of . . . ” (Jameson, Postmodernism).

We will have to come back to some of those quotes above, stay with them, wander in their desolation and refusals. The anti-anti-communist Jameson, the sci-fi author, Jameson. What will we read?

Some ideas (aside from those mentioned above like the Blaft Book of Anti-Caste SF):

Dillon, G. L. (Ed.). (2013). Walking the clouds : an anthology of indigenous science fiction. University of Arizona Press. http://www.gbv.de/dms/sub-hamburg/668230606.pdf

Sartre, J.P. (2004) Critique of Dialectical Reason: Theory of practical ensembles (Vol. 1). Verso.

Fehrle, J., Lieber, M. and Ramirez, J.J., 2024. (De) automating the future: Marxist perspectives on capitalism and technology (Vol. 321). Brill.

Shelly, M. 1817. Frankenstein.

Wells, H.G., 2003. The war of the worlds. Broadview Press.

Milner, A., 2018. Again, dangerous visions: essays in cultural materialism. In Again, Dangerous Visions: Essays in Cultural Materialism. Brill.

Unpayable Debt by Denise Ferreira da Silva

Butler, Octavia E., 2004. Kindred. Beacon Press.

I witnessed together with others–as a collective act–‘Rememberment’, a devastating lecture performance by Jasbir Puar and Dima Srouji on the coloniality of gender and the genocide ongoing in Palestine.1 The description of the intervention performed previously at the Institute for Contemporary Art in Los Angeles provided by the artists reads:

“What does the coloniality of gender mean during a genocide? The carnage in Gaza is replete with gendered forms of violence. Scenes of bodily humiliation and mutilation have been screaming from our screens for more than a year now. Working through and against the grain of this obvious, ubiquitous archive, Puar and Srouji excavate the longue durée of the imposition of gender binarism in Gaza and conversely, also foreground the praxis of “re-member-ment” that exceed such mandates and highlight Palestinian determination to become differently whole.”

https://www.theicala.org/en/events/1297-the-coloniality-of-gender-in-real-time-jasbir-puar-dima-srouji

After the performance I witnessed in London, one of the organisers of the workshop remarked that it made him want never to deliver another academic lecture again. Something happened in the performance, an act of collective witnessing of the genocide that momentarily and powerfully created a different affective relation to both the zionist genocide and to Palestinians becoming differently whole.

What is the temporality of becoming differently whole? What of the time of genocide? How is that time lived, when does it become unlivable in Gaza, the West Bank, in the Galilee, in the diaspora, when does it become differently whole? Jasbir reminded me of what is at stake politically and ethically. In the affective transformation of the room, Jasbir felt “like I was conducting something, I was conducting people through” … a ritual of remembrance, involving the multiple silences interspersed throughout the piece and in the long silence that greeted its first performance in LA. Puar says she has learned something about the need today for silence in collective spaces. Puar and Srouji tactical produced different and opaque affective relationships to Palestine beyond outrage or disgust, toward a witnessing without familiar affects.

We who are non-Palestinian Palestinians, we who are in Black study with Palestinian revolutionaries, honoured and commemorated that erased time by bearing collective witness to ‘Rememberment’.

The performed piece brought up the problem of time and social domination, of the gendered coloniality of western cardinal time vs the ordinal time of the non-linear becoming of the Palestinian people. But there was no clear and distinct binary posited here between bad colonial time and good revolutionary time: the performance juxtaposed image-sound-text-voice in a strategic yet opaque assemblage of sense and image, and staying with their opacities in a dialectics of time, land, movement, and prostheses entangled in the multiplicity that is Palestinian liberation.

For instance, in the performance an estranging oscillation of timespace occurs in the visual juxtaposition of film footage of Israeli soldiers homoerotically training in the 1950s with sci-fi looking computer simulations of dismembered, abstracted body parts in CAD, (im)mediated by Jasbir’s voice reading passages from Ghassan Kanafani’s revolutionary short story “Letter from Gaza” (remember: “it’s just the beginning,” Kanafani wrote). This as a kind of machinic orchestra of violence and resistance conjoins the ambient sounds of genocide as Jasbir speaks, sometimes her pitch matching the din, sometimes in contrast subdued and mourning. Imagine all this as you hear Puar’s scathing analysis historicising Rabin’s ‘break their bones’ policy. Jasbir had spoken of temporality in terms of “the normative timeframes of before, during, after” in her talk the day before (which she shared with me).

Repair, Puar writes, is “dialectical, holding open space for trauma and vision, grief and hope” (she references the work of Khaldun Bshara). Drawing on Emilio Distretti (one of the co-organisers of the conference at the RCA, where I witnessed the performance) she argues that repair is not the end of mourning “but its continuation–a labor through which the broken is given another kind of life” (see the Collection on Repair and Palestine in E-Flux) Whether we agree if its dialectical or not, what is certain is that concepts of repair and repair praxis are together a radical multiplicity of organisation, media, movement, and affect.

Theorising genocide, Puar’s work focuses on the forms of maiming, debilitation, and slow death that Patrick Wolfe calls “structural genocide.” Following Wolfe, Puar makes the critical affirmation of genocide as both structure and event. In this, settler colonial time is “served by confining genocide to eventness and so at stake are epistemic refusals and epistemic repair.”

In critical conversation with Fred Moten she marks how genocide in Gaza is this continual maiming and associated slow death, which “moves in the non-space between killing each and every one and the constantly cultivated, measured, and tested inability to kill all” (quoting Fred Moten).

Juridically, Puar notes, the 1948 international Genocide Convention defines genocide as “acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group,” it also states that genocide is “deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part” (she is quoting from the Genocide Convention, Article II c). Puar’s work shows how legal and political interpretations of genocide conveniently focus on intentional mass killing, “allowing states to avoid a definitional range that could be applied to their own practices of slow violence, organized abandonment, and debilitation.”

The bio and the necro form of politics and administration constitutes one contradictory whole in settler colonial states such as Israel. This ‘bio-necropolitical collaboration’ institutes both a politics of extermination and a politics of living in negation (the cancelled time of social death; Hortense Spillers is an important interlocutor for Puar). “To understand genocide as the negation and not only the elimination of life is to attend to both the massive scale of annihilation along with the minutia of deprivation.”

Image credits: Courtesy Jason Williams

What does the coloniality of gender mean during a genocide?

The carnage in Gaza is replete with gendered forms of violence. Scenes of bodily humiliation and mutilation have been screaming from our screens for more than a year now. Working through and against the grain of this obvious, ubiquitous archive, Puar and Srouji excavate the longue durée of the imposition of gender binarism in Gaza and conversely, also foreground the praxis of “re-member-ment” that exceed such mandates and highlight Palestinian determination to become differently whole.

What emerges in Puar’s written work is the critical concept of the paraontological status of the maimed Palestinian. This is a concept that she explicitly puts in conversation with the para-existence of Black people subject to the social death of white supremacy, the paradoxical conditions of which are brought out most strikingly in the Black radical tradition, in the work of among others W. E. B. Dubois, R. Ellison, Z. N. Hurston, O. Paterson, F. Wildersen, F. Moten, H. Spillers, J. Sexton, D. Warren, R.D.G. Kelly, F. Fanon, E. Glissant, R. Wright, A. Y. Davis, R. W. Gilmore, S. Hartman, and C. Sharpe.2 Puar’s work consistently articulates the Black radical tradition with Palestinian liberation through the strategic conjuncture of (negative) ontology.

Time and the temporalities of genocidal conjunctures had been a consistent theme in the activist-academic conversations around repair, reparations, and the affirmation of the right to return for Palestinians, Jasbir told me later. There had been a tense lecture presentation just before their performance, and also part of the procedings, a presentation by a member of Forensic Architecture. Goldsmiths-based Forensic Architecture founded by Eyal Weizman is a radical politico-aesthetic practice that helps to visualise, for example, the materiality of genocide in Palestine and racist state violence in Brazil in order to intervene through the juridical apparatus (i.e. authenticating admissible evidence in a court of law), but not necessarily to politicise FA’s own mode of visuality-as-evidence/proof of the genocide and Zionism’s crimes against humanity. As one Palestinian women from the audience put it after the FA presentation, ‘We don’t need FA to authenticate what we know we have lost’ (not a direct quote). The tension here was about the strategy of memory and witnessing that can activate a silenced and colonized past.

This contestation of temporality was precisely what ‘Rememberment’ took as its domain of action. The Palestinians are constructing a collective subjectivity in excess of the Zionist biopolitical state: If the maimed Palestinian child will need a new prosthetic every 6 months, ‘how do we plan for tomorrow? There is a tomorrow for these children.’ (Abu-Sitta)

This problematisation of a liberatory strategy of memory for and by Palestinians, and the role of collective witnessing for Palestinians and non-Palestinian palestinians, was at stake in the performance of ‘Rememberment’, presented through sensorily opaque and yet analytically incisive assemblages/series of voice-pause-image-sound stream-pause. It was presented in such a way that did not disavow vulnerability, despair, rage, and affirmed the courage of refusal and resistance in the everyday life of Palestinians ….

The performance left me cold, silent, numb … overwhelmed by the sheer scale of the atrocities piling up in the genocide . . . A sense emerging that Zionism is a genocidal machine that murders Palestinian and then exhibits and re-captures the genocided in a pornography of humanitarian pain. Ashlaa’ (the gathering of body parts) refusing the machine. After the performance, I was itching to move, desiring somehow to continue to witness, to refuse the silencing of thousands and thousands Palestinian bodies dismembered, bulldozed, or now recently vaporised toward erasure in Gaza. The genocide keeps piling up its surplus populations.

I will keep returning to Puar and Srouji’s performance which insistently poses to non-Palestinians their ethical relations to the ongoing revolutionary becoming of the Palestinian people.

In the performance, Puar’s spoken text stays with the contemporary implications of her study of the “Right to Maim” (2017) as a prescient analysis of the technofetishistic precursors that primed the world for the slow death of the genocide unfolding before us. The sound stream is haunting, machinic, fracturing, atmospheric, opaque. Together, Puar and Srouji displace the technofetishistic practices Israel institutes throughout the occupied territories. For example, the IDF policy of shooting the knees and legs of Palestinians: this is an example of what Puar fearlessly calls out as “Israel’s heinous acts of maiming and dismemberment.” Her text speaks of the encirclement of Southern Lebanon and Beirut, and the historical and biopolitical articulations of a value hierarchy between Israelis and Palestinians.

In another section of the performance, Israel’s nation branding through pink washing is linked to the heteropatriarchal and racial capitalist underpinnings of the Zionist state. Queer Progressive Israel will liberate the supposedly backward Arabs — but here the jouissance of supposedly progressive queer liberation is smothered in the temporalities of genocide which incorporate both in its relentless advance. The intersectional struggles of queer Palestinians are used as a foil for the occupation of Palestine. This amounts to merely a queer justification for the genocide, argues Puar. This queer zionism (small z) turns the other way when confronted with the homophobia and transphobia in Netanyahu’s cabinet, as Puar notes. It’s end of the liberal facade–it’s been ending for a while now. Capitalist exploitation, dispossession, normativity: Queer Israel is the liberal subject of a kind of cruel jouissance. Here, the disavowed imperial subject of queer and trans rights is the secret sharer of zionism (small z).

The performance interposes an audio clip from a recorded message of Jasbir speaking at a free Palestine event. Reading from a manifesto written by the collective Queers in Palestine, she speaks together with them of the “radical resistance we embody. We are still moved by the force of life.” Her dialectical words, her fragile and fearless voice joins with the image stream and the punctuations of Srouji’s montage together refusing to be complicit in the social death of the Palestinian people.

The text is complex, precise, nonlinear. Puar says that queer feminist radical truths cannot be quantified. Action and transformation and abolition as refusal of all structures that are designed to erase the colonized is what the world needs now. Puar brings in the work of decolonial feminist Maria Lugones (1944-2020), whose analysis of the modern colonial gender system shows how gender is structurally narrowed to control sex. Puar links the coloniality of gender and indigenous peoples history of resistance in the Americas to the Black radical tradition and the analysis of queer necropolitical Zionism. Soldiers parading in the lingerie of women they have just killed. The amputation crisis. Heteronormative gender binarism happening in and through the Israeli genocide of the Palestinean people and their ecologies. Dismantling of social cohesion, reduction in birthrates. The queer branding wars in the settler colony. Even the stones had meaning. Puar quotes Srouji, Srouji’s audiovisuals resonate with Puar’s analysis. The disciplining of time . . . The ground bears evidence of the resilience of the Palestinian people, the memory… The archaeology of the tunnels, and the ground as battlefield and sanctuary, the ground bears witness against the ethnic cleansing.

Image credits: Courtesy Jason Williams


What does the coloniality of gender mean during a genocide?

The carnage in Gaza is replete with gendered forms of violence. Scenes of bodily humiliation and mutilation have been screaming from our screens for more than a year now. Working through and against the grain of this obvious, ubiquitous archive, Puar and Srouji excavate the longue durée of the imposition of gender binarism in Gaza and conversely, also foreground the praxis of “re-member-ment” that exceed such mandates and highlight Palestinian determination to become differently whole.

“Every layer of soil is testament to a vibrant and enduring culture that refuses to be extinguished.”

“The truth is we will remain.”

Silence, superimposed image streams of old footage of land and artefacts . . .

Part of the performance, toward the end, is a video clip of Dr. Nadera Shalhoub Kevorkian speaking of ashlaa’ as a re-ontological practice; the ontological and epistemological erasure of the Palestinians is the material and spiritual conditions of the making of ashlaa’, body parts, as ontological reclamation. Refusing non-being is ashlaa’, is a practice of rememberment. Rememberment is ontological, psychic, pedagogical, re-cohering. We are here to witness, to bear witness as rememberment, to affirm Palestine as paradigm.

Image credits: Courtesy Jason Williams


What does the coloniality of gender mean during a genocide?



The carnage in Gaza is replete with gendered forms of violence. Scenes of bodily humiliation and mutilation have been screaming from our screens for more than a year now. Working through and against the grain of this obvious, ubiquitous archive, Puar and Srouji excavate the longue durée of the imposition of gender binarism in Gaza and conversely, also foreground the praxis of “re-member-ment” that exceed such mandates and highlight Palestinian determination to become differently whole.

What finally is ashlaa’? Puar connects the IDF’s deliberate strategy of maiming Palestinians to the practice of ‘gathering of body parts’: Nadera Shalhoub Kevorkian remarks how in Arabic the ‘dismemberment and rememberment of limbs and flesh’ is known as ashlaa’, a new habit of the residents of Gaza thanks to the genocide and its slow deaths. Following Shalhoub Kevorkian, Puar notes that ashlaa’ is a praxis of ‘epistemic reunification’ and ‘ontological reclamation’ (both N.S.K.’s formulations) that subverts the abject category of non-being. Puar argues that this is not only a reunification and reclamation of flesh but also of kin and land. “The father gathers his children in a plastic bag, refusing to orphan them and refusing to be childless. Palestinians in Gaza buy pounds of flesh in order to carry out burial rituals, refusing to treat flesh as anonymous and mere matter” (Puar forthcoming).

Puar writes:

“Far from minor gestures, in these acts of rememberment, maiming is not normalized but ritually resisted. These practices transform injury into political witness and relational continuity. Corporeal repair thus involves a radical rethinking of what a body is. In Abu-Sittah’s words, an amputated limb must become a “badge of honor,” not the mark of a disabled life as lack, but of life lived in radical refusal of colonial ontology. I would suggest more than this, the amputated limb opens to a dialectical para-ontology that is beside or lateral to the binarized terms of colonial capture, thus unsuturing the desired totalization of colonial power.”

Puar sees the parameters of bio-necropolitical power marked not by the thresholds of life and death, but instead by the gradients of livability and unlivability. This dialectic is always being exceeded by the multiplicities it seeks and seems to binarise.

“Recall that in 2012 the UN stated that Gaza would be unlivable by 2020. Livability/unlivability is less a binary of normative humanistic measures and more about who is consigned to navigate ever-shifting zones of modulation, calibration, elasticity.”

The ontology of Palestinian life and death defy the “normative metrics of a livable, and therefore valuable, life.” Puar conceptualises this “will not let die” of the wounded as para-ontological the operations of which remain “opaque to colonial logic.” As Abourahme has noted and as Puar affirms, ashlaa’ is a refusal to submit to settler colonial time.

For her, this is precisely where the “right to opacity” and the paraontological commune. Ashlaa’ is a practice of “will not let die” driven by the re-member-ment of the dismembered, a commitment to memory, ritual, and the presence in, on, underneath the land. As Dima Srouji writes, “Ashlaa’ becomes a methodology: a way of being with what is broken, of touching what remains, and of seeing in the fragment not loss but latency” (from her E-Flux article, qtd. in Puar forthcoming).

But take the Palestinian practice of ashlaa’ as a paradigm for a dissability communism and then consider the protocols of planning and design after the genocide. Puar asks what would it mean to make impairment—and actually dismemberment—central to reconstruction efforts?

“Collective repair therefore requires community-based interpretive frameworks that resist the commodification and depoliticization of suffering. Collective repair also resists social fragmentation. Colonial violence frequently attempts to weaponize injury to produce stigma, isolation, and social death. Communities of the wounded therefore become sites of resistance, producing alternative infrastructures of care and belonging. This is also an observation about our solidarity organizing spaces –protesting the mass mutilation of life in Gaza while maintaining status quo ableism while doing so….What debility forces is a reckoning with our own participation and normalization of social reproduction as slow death. Collective repair is future-oriented. It is not about returning to a pre-violence past but about creating conditions for different futures — futures that remember forward, not just backward.” (Puar forthcoming)

  1. Jasbir K. Puar is Distinguished Faculty of Arts Professor in the Social Justice Institute at the University of British Columbia. She is the author of the award-winning books The Right to Maim: Debility, Capacity, Disability (2017), which has been translated into Spanish and Portuguese, and Terrorist Assemblages: Homonationalism in Queer Times (2007), available in French and Spanish, re-issued as an expanded version for its 10th anniversary (2017), and forthcoming in Portuguese. Her articles have been published in journals such as Social Text and South Atlantic Quarterly, mainstream venues such as Al-Jazeera and The Guardian, and translated into more than 15 languages. Dr. Puar is also co-author of exhibitions for the Sharjah Architecture Triennial (2019) and the Sharjah Art Biennial (2023). In 2019 she received the Kessler Award from the Center for Gay and Lesbian Studies (CLAGS) at CUNY, which recognizes lifetime achievement in and impact on queer research and organizing. Dima Srouji is a Palestinian architect and visual artist exploring the ground as a deep space of rich cultural weight and a space for potential collective repair. Srouji looks for ruptures in the ground where imaginary liberation is possible. She works with glass, text, archives, maps, plaster casts, and film, understanding each as an evocative object and emotional companion that help her question what cultural heritage and public space means. ↩︎
  2. See: Fanon F (2021) The Wretched of the Earth. London: Black Cat; Gilmore RW (2022) Abolition geography. London: Verso; Glissant É (1997) Poetics of relation. Ann Arbor: UMP; Hartman S (2008) Lose your mother. London: Macmillan; Hartman S (2022) Scenes of subjection: Terror, slavery, and self-making in nineteenth-century America. New York: WW Norton; Moten F (2017) Black and blur. Durham: DUP; Okiji F (2018) Jazz as critique. Palo Alto: SUP; Okoth KO (2023) Red Africa: Reclaiming Revolutionary Black Politics. London: Verso; Robinson CJ (2020) Black Marxism. Charlotte: UNC Press; Sharpe, C. (2016). In the wake: On blackness and being. Durham: DUP; Davis, A.Y. (2015) Freedom Is a Constant Struggle: Ferguson, Palestine, and the Foundations of a Movement. Haymarket Books, Chicago; ↩︎

If the grounds of late fascism (cf. Banaji, 2016, 2024; Toscano, 2023; Sadaawi, 2025, S. Hall)1 in the UK have been prepared by both liberals and conservatives (the fascist political economic totality) for the past three decades, we could do no better towards an affective diagramming2 of UK’s changing abstract machine of fascism it seems to me than to tune in and tune out the double-speak on the far-right propaganda channel ‘GB news–The People’s News Channel, Britain’s News Channel’ (available in the USA on Trump’s ‘Truth Plus’).

Some GB News tagline: “Because the Truth Matters and so do You.” “Double whammy calamity [David] Lammy [this coverage was interesting because the commentators are complaining about the authoritarianism of Lammy’s decision to remove juries from trials, giving undue power to magistrates…fascists care about your freedoms…]…”Everything, everything is racist,” inveighs the bilious Martin Daubney. “Just last week on GB News I interviewed Nigel Farage and he made his position clear. [Quoting Farage] “I’ve been a big supporter of Jewish rights [on-going erasure of Palestine and Palestinian rights on GB News is seemingly total], and everyone knows that.” Blistering attacks on Nigel Farage! …Farage charged with racism, but it happened over 50 years ago.” What are they talking about at the Dog and Duck (pub–apparently that’s where authentic Britain drinks and discusses politics)? An entire third of children in Glasgow–a city of sanctuary–who is paying for these people?” (Daubney) Response from a Scottish commentator: “Gaelic and Scots are recognised languages, and because English is not the refugees’ first language, doesn’t mean they don’t speak English. How are they integrating into wider society?” Is this about white people? “I didn’t say that,” squeaks Daubney. “The best curries are in Glasgow, they are very diverse.” The rate of immigration is part of the problem, according to the posh accented commentator. “There is no integration today, as there was when I immigrated here” (a South Asian conservative MP).

But is GB News fascist or is it better described as part of a ‘parafascist’ project? A. A. Ross has provided a succinct definition of the latter:

“Parafascism: “The term parafascist here connotes a more genuinely authoritarian and conservative ideology than the radical right. Scholars Payne and Griffin identify Francisco Franco, Ioannis Metaxas, and Juan Perón, for instance, as parafascists who embrace some form of corporatism or vertical syndicalism as a model of state-driven economic power but typically lack a “mass movement” base that fascists attempt to generate and lead. While Perón’s descamisados and the cult Franco created around “martyred” fascist leader José Antonio Primo de Rivera did produce the semblance of mass movements, their regimes relied more on the bureaucratization of syndicalism from above and a conservative military establishment than any ultranationalist “revolution from below. ” For this reason, parafascism has also been called ‘fascism from above’.” (A. A. Ross, 2016 Against the Fascist Creep, A. K. Press))

Fascism from above? But isn’t GB News the ‘people’s news’–‘Britain’s News Channel’, where ‘everyday’ people get to ‘have their say’? The media assemblage that is GB news expresses a historically specific ‘ecology of sensation’ or political economy of perception rooted in violent anti-Blackness, nationalism, militarism, xenophobia, worker (super)exploitation, extraction, misogyny, denial of the genocide ongoing in Gaza, and obfuscations of the real abstractions of derivative-driven finance (cf Toscano and Bhandar on real abstractions; see O’Kane on real abstractions–a profoundly influential concept today, drawing on Adorno, Simmel, and in some definite ways W. Benjamin). GB News is owned by holding company All Perspectives Ltd. Take that in for a moment: an extreme right-wing ‘news’ outlet is ‘held’ by something calling itself ‘all perspectives.’ Contra Viveiros de Castro’s Cannibal Metaphysics and the Amerindian thought of perspectivism, this organisation is a right-wing fringe group, parafascist, Christian and Zionist. Such absurdly obvious prevarications as the name ‘all perspectives’ summons up the good and common sense of some kind of democracy of opinions and viewpoints–such ideological sleights of hand, like the turn of the screw in Henry James and Viveiros de Castro, intensify the contradictions as we delve deeper into the fascist corporate ecosystem of GB News. The major investors in this holding company include hedge fund manager Paul Marshall (and probably his brother) and the Dubai-based investment group Legatum. As AI’s internet search tells us seemingly innocuously, “The channel is widely regarded as having a right-leaning political stance” and that the Legatum group has “drawn scrutiny for its political connections and ideological leanings.” What’s the structure of the Legatum group considered from an organizational viewpoint?

What is the Legatum Group? Founded December 2006 by New Zealand-born investor Christopher Chandler (Wikipedia), the Legatum Group is headquartered in Dubai, UAE; it invests only partners’ capital. UBS is a partner, for instance, and through UBS Optimus Foundation is an investor in several of Legatum’s philanthropic funds, including the END Fund, the Freedom Fund, and the Luminos Fund. As their website tells us:

“Organisation: Our desire to contribute to the creation of a more prosperous world doesn’t just shape what we do, it defines who we are as an organisation.”

https://www.legatum.com/about/organisation/

The specific and momentary leadership of the legatum group [Christopher Chandler (Chairman), Alan McCormick (Partner), and Philip Vassiliou (Chief Investment Officer)] . . . is to an extent incidental to the late fascist agenda. What do I mean by the ‘late fascist agenda’? Drawing on Toscano, Bhandar, Banaji, Moten, Puar, Fanon, Mbembe, Clough, Massumi, Glissant, Postone, Manning, Adorno, Kracauer, Rosenberg (“Fascism as a mass-movement” [1933])3 and well like a lot of others, we can say that a certain assemblage of multi-racial representational practices has seemingly (oh, yes, don’t forget Hegel) alchemized the historically specific racist representations of Black people, people of colour, natives and the indigenous, the Irish, southern Italians, Welsh, Basque, Dalits, Mahars, Gypsies, and other Others with a more and more strident affirmation of fascist white supremacy and unfettered capitalist accumulation for (mostly–see the earlier part of this sentence) white capital (Robinson 2013).

The following year this same motley (not motley enough, alas) crew of ‘activist’ speculators donated significant funds to found MIT’s Legatum Center–now the Kuo Sharper Center, from where this person of Bangladeshi heritage publishes this article in 2014):

Ford and McDonald’s? Not great examples of the investor class ‘caring’ for poor people, but never mind. Do keep in mind who the key investors in All Perspectives, Ltd. are: Paul Marshall – a hedge fund tycoon known for supporting right-wing causes and the Legatum Group – a Dubai-based investment firm with conservative-leaning interests. Let’s not loose site of that. But there are other shareholders; some presenters and staff, including Nigel Farage, Michelle Dewberry, and Andrew Doyle, have small shareholdings, though collectively less than 1% of voting stock. The CEO of GN News is Angelos Frangopoulos, formerly of Sky News Australia, also a right-leaning populist ‘news’ source.

The synthesized internet (AI) tells us: “GB News positions itself as a challenger to the BBC and Sky News, aiming to give more airtime to “ordinary voices.” However, its association with right-wing figures and investors has cemented its reputation as a conservative-leaning broadcaster” (generative AI from prompt ‘what are the politics of GB News’).

What does the Legatum group invest in, other than fascist news outlets?

Philanthropy: Through the Legatum Institute Foundation, the group funds initiatives such as:

The END Fund – tackling neglected tropical diseases.

The Luminos Fund – supporting education for children excluded due to poverty or war.

The Freedom Fund – combating ‘modern slavery’ (source: GB News).

What’s Legatum’s ‘Philosophy’? Legatum frames its mission around “prosperity as a mindset,” blending investment with social impact (source: Legatum). Legatum expounds what they term a compensation philosophy:

At Legatum, we believe that everyone is born with a gift. This gift has been given to help us achieve our purpose in life. Our purpose is not something we choose, it is something we discover.

How banal, how commonplace, how wholesome, how, as Patrick Keiler might say, ‘homegrown’.4 On GB News, from the standpoint of this viewer, it seems that only rich white people are born with a gift: money, money, and more money. Oh and white privilege itself. But whiteness is a black hole, sometimes embarrassingly mired in the vortex of its own ressentiments, sometimes on proud display like a shiny new St George flag on the lamposts of Canary Wharf–the contradictions of race and the culture wars on GB News multiply chaotically and with definite patterns and affective atmospheres. We will have to return to the affective resonations that pulsate wildly in GB news’ black hole of whiteness . . .

Political Connections and ‘Controversies’ of Legatum Group

To begin with UK Politics, in which a kind of ‘dual’ power already exists (we will return to Jameson’s Leninist thesis of dual power and the universal army . . . ):5 The Legatum Institute donates to Conservative Party factions, “including a £50,000 gift to the ‘New Conservatives’ group of MPs in 2023.”6 On climate policy, investigations suggest Legatum funds organisations opposed to climate action, aligning with its support for GB News, which frequently hosts climate-skeptic voices (ibid). In terms of reccent history, Legatum had a Brexit influence, playing a significant role shaping Brexit policy debates, producing reports and lobbying for a hard Brexit stance, which in liberal quarters raised questions about ‘foreign influence in UK politics’. As if.

So that’s a quick resume of Legatum group, part of a broader far-right media capture of attention. What is its affective and infrastructural diagram?

—

That diagram would include the real abstractions of racial capitalist risks to Reputation of Legatum. This risk is in present-day criticism of the investment group, based in Dubai–did I already mention that? In its own branding, we get the ‘Positive framing’: Legatum promotes itself as a force for global good, claiming to have impacted over 400 million lives in 100+ countries through its philanthropic ventures (claimed on GB News). Bourgeois analysts and liberal-libertarian watchdogs argue that its political donations, media ownership, and ideological projects reveal a strong conservative agenda, particularly in the UK. This is part of a strategy, a dual strategy of corprorate opacity–there are, um, transparency concerns: as Legatum is privately held and based offshore, liberal critics highlight the opacity of its funding sources and influence networks.

This research on Legatum must copntinue, and must be part of a broader information commons against fascism. Legatum is a fascist dual power operative in the UK today; it is a financial investor that is politically active for revanchism, ideologically and financially driven to be a “Global Axiomatic for Racial Capital” organisation. While it funds what seem to be humanitarian projects (and a feminist, queer, anti-imperialist, anti-capitalist, and intersectionally complex audit of these projects is still to come in this blog), its ownership of GB News and donations to UK political factions suggest a deliberate attempt to shape public discourse along far right-leaning, climate-skeptic, and populist lines, making a review of GB News a review of Late Fascism.

Should Muslims ‘be allowed to’ celebrate Eid in Trafalgar square? That’s the debate tonight–20 March, 2026–It’s racist and Islamophobic to say that some (usually unspecified) ‘radical Islamic sects’ want to take over the British public sphere. Right-wing, Reform spokesperson/white hope: “I support what Nigel Farage has said, do we want an authoritarian government? If the Greens get what they want than in about twenty years we are going to run into hard authoritarian. Is this a Christian country? Of course it is. Everyone but the Muslims believe that this is a Christian country.” They cut away after that to focus on a human interest story involving ‘sexy gnomes’.

The next evening, the debate continues on why in a Christian country Muslims should not be allowed to “dominate” over white Christian Britain by celebrating Eid in Trafalgar. “I want a Christian country of British culture, and respect for those British values. And acceptance by everyone to assimilate to those values. I’m not a racist, my friend was there and she felt attacked…We have to be critical of Islamicist ideology.” “What do you intend to do?” asks a working class Black commentator, “Kick out every single Muslim from this country?” They segued into a segment on the South Asian grooming gangs (“Muslim rape gangs”) scandal and “Starmer’s lack of clear response” (according to a Reform commentator). Race, ethnicity, religion are the central areas of concern according to the white female commentator. “Little white girls are going on being raped,” says the visibly shaken white woman. And so through articulations of race, sexuality, gender, class, religion, and nation are entangled the Other’s affects–Muslims otherised in the constitution of the patriotic white Briton. Spivak once called this process the “Self-consolidating Other.”

  1. Ghalya Saadawi, (October 3, 2025) “Against History: Art, Culture, and Business-as-Usual under the Gazan Genocide,” Salvage, https://salvage.zone/against-history-art-culture-and-business-as-usual-under-the-gazan-genocide/; cf Toscano A (2023) Late Fascism: Race, Capitalism and the Politics of Crisis. London: Verso; Zarabadi, S., 2022. The Theatre of Everyday Debt-Cruelty: The Enfleshed Threat, Missing People And The Unbearable Strange Terrorist Machine. In Deleuze and Guattari and Fascism, Rick Dolphijn and Rosi Braidotti, eds. Edinburgh: EUP. Pp. 125-143; Bhatty K and Sundar N (2020) Sliding from majoritarianism toward fascism: Educating India under the Modi regime. International Sociology 35(6): 632-650; Gago, Verónica (2025) The fascistisation of social reproduction. Radical Philosophy 2(18): 23-34; for an experimentation in decolonial political economy of Palestine see Tartir, A., Dana, T. and Seidel, T. eds., 2021. Political economy of Palestine: Critical, interdisciplinary, and decolonial perspectives. London: Springer Nature; and Roy, S., 1987. The Gaza Strip: A case of economic de-development. Journal of Palestine Studies, 17(1), pp.56-88. For Stuart Hall’s varied contribution to understanding the creeping fascism in UK politics see for instance:
    Hall, S. (1967) The Young Englanders, London, Community Relations Commission.
    Hall, S. (1970) ‘Black Britons’, Community, vol. 1, pp. 3 5.
    Hall, S. (1973) ‘Encoding and decoding in the media discourse’, CCCS stencilled
    paper, University of Birmingham.
    Hall, S. (1978) ‘Racism and reaction’, in Five Views of Multi-Racial Britain, London,
    Commission for Racial Equality.
    Hall, S. (1980) ‘Race, articulation and societies structured in dominance’,
    reprinted 1996 in Black British Cultural Studies: A Reader, eds. H. A. Baker, M.
    Diawara & R. H. Lindeborg, Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press.
    Hall, S. (1986) ‘Gramsci’s relevance for the study of race and ethnicity’, reprinted
    1996 in Stuart Hall: Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies, eds. D. Morley & K.
    H. Chen, London, Routledge.
    Hall, S. (1988) The Hard Road to Renewal, London, Verso.
    Hall, S. (1990) ‘Cultural identity and diaspora’, in Identity: Community, Culture,
    Difference, ed. J. Rutherford, London, Lawrence & Wishart.
    Hall, S. (1991) ‘Old and new identities, old and new ethnicities’, in Culture,
    Globalisation and the World System, ed. A. King, Basingstoke, Macmillan.
    Hall, S. (1992) ‘New ethnicities’, in ‘Race’, Culture and Difference , eds. J. Donald &
    A. Rattansi, London, Sage. (Originally published in 1988.)
    Hall, S. (1996a) ‘Cultural studies: two paradigms’, in What is Cultural Studies? A
    Reader, ed. J. Story, London, Arnold Press.
    Hall, S. (1996b) ‘The formation of a diasporic intellectual: an interview with
    Stuart Hall’, in Stuart Hall: Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies, eds D.
    Morley & K. H. Chen, London, Routledge.
    Hall, S. (1996c) ‘Minimal selves’, in Black British Cultural Studies: A Reader, eds H.
    A. Baker, M. Diawara & R.H. Lindeborg, Chicago, IL, University of
    Chicago Press. (Originally published in 1987.)
    Hall, S. (1996d) ‘Cultural studies and its theoretical legacies’, in Stuart Hall:
    Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies, eds D. Morley & K. H. Chen, London,
    Routledge.
    Hall, S. (1996e) ‘When was the postcolonial? Thinking at the Limit’, in The
    Postcolonial Question, eds I. Chambers & L. Curti, London, Routledge.
    Hall, S. (2000a) ‘The multicultural question’, in Un/Settled Multiculturalisms, ed.
    B. Hesse, London, Zed Press.
    Hall, S. (2000b) ‘Frontlines/backyards’, in Black British Culture and Society, ed. K.
    Owusu, London, Routledge.
    Hall, S. & Jacques, M. (eds) (1989) New Times, London, Lawrence & Wishart.
    Hall, S. & Jefferson, T. (eds) (1976) Resistance through Rituals: Youth Subcultures in
    Postwar Britain, London, Hutchinson.
    Hall, S., et al. (1978) Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State and Law and Order,
    Basingstoke, Macmillan. ↩︎
  2. What is an affective diagrammatics of the emergent body in racial capitalist circuits of valorisation and exchange? This is to be posed better, that is for the benefit of actions to come. ↩︎
  3. Printed in Banaji, J. ed., 2013. Fascism: Essays on Europe and India. New Delhi: Three Essays Collective Publications; cf García H (2016) Transnational History: A New Paradigm for Anti-Fascist Studies? Contemporary European History, 25(4), 563–572; Haiven M (2023) From Financialization to Derivative Fascisms: Some Cultural Politics of Far-Right Authoritarianism in an Era of Unmanageable Risk. Social Text, 41(2): 45-73; Halász, K. (2025) ‘Capacities to be a Body out of Bounds’, in Gregory J. Seigworth, Mathew Arthur, Wendy J. Truran, Chad Shomura (eds). Capacities To: Affect Up Against Fascism. Lancaster, PA; Vancouver: Imbricate! Press, pp. 15 – 23; Luger, Jason & Miller, Jacob (2025). The Capacity to Generate the Gratuitous Violence of America’s New Ruins. In Gregory Seigworth, Mathew Arthur, Wendy Truran, and Chad Shomura, (Eds.), Capacities To: Affect Up Against Fascism (pp. 81-90). Vancouver: Imbricate; Maher, Henry (2023). Neoliberal fascism? Fascist trends in early neoliberal thought and echoes in the present. Contemporary Political Theory, 23, 392–410; Massumi, Brian (2025). The Personality of Power: A Theory of Fascism for Anti-Fascist Life. Durham: Duke University Press. ↩︎
  4. See London, 1994, dir. Keiller, P. ↩︎
  5. Jameson, F., 2016. An American utopia: Dual power and the universal army. New York: Verso Books. ↩︎
  6. Conservative Faction Receives £50,000 from GB News Owner
    The Dubai-based Legatum Group funds multiple organisations that have advocated against climate action. Sam Bright, Jan 18, 2024, https://www.desmog.com/2024/01/18/new-conservatives-faction-donation-50000-gb-news-owner-legatum-group/ ↩︎

…If the people of India breed too fast, it’s no concern of ours. We’re supposed to feel sorry for them because they’re starving. Well, some of us don’t feel sorry: we feel glad. Let them starve, let them die. Let them starve at least, or…”Strike! Strike!…built factories, sent them tanks and tractors, helped them build and run their governments. And in return we don’t just take the raw materials we need; we buy their shoddy clothes and trinkets, too……perhaps in the house next to you, with their laziness, promiscuity, and sordid homes. Now, we’re not racialists, but the way these people live is filthy, as you’d see if you went to look at the backstreets of Wolverhampton today. These people just don’t accept our standards of civilization. They live in filth and squalor. They breed like rabbits, and they suck our social services dry. Unless we put a stop to the influx of this horde, our cities will soon be so full of aliens that we won’t recognize them…… seeing whole areas of our land transformed into alien territory…” British Sounds, 1970, Goddard, dir.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/3643823/Enoch-Powells-Rivers-of-Blood-speech.html

Enoch Powell, “Rivers of Blood” speech (full text)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivers_of_Blood_speech

Why are you glaring at me white man? Remember, Fanon’s memory in Black Skin, White Masks, the innocent white child said: “Look maman, a Negro, I’m afraid.” What is it about non-white people that makes them-us-me so . . . so . . . fearful, so un-human, so … ‘filthy’ (and hence desirable-repulsive) — to white people?

Why are you following me white dude? What are all those sign-particles1 tattooed on your neck, is it a swastika or … ? Your shaved white head, it looks … so clean, so pure. But what are you glaring at me for? What do you want me to fear about you, fear your purity, fear your threatened violence?

I’m in a gym one of the many in London owned by the same ‘charity’, a semi-public space going from ‘better’-to-bad-to-worse. I’ve been going every other day to manage the pain in my shoulder; I have torn ligaments, a SLAP tear to be precise… Anyway, so–I’m in my gym, after having run 8.65 km around the athletics track in an hour and a half, my longest distance yet (acc. to my phone’s activity tracker). Yes, I was filthy with sweat. And I want to say as if in proleptic defence that I had towelled myself dry and sprayed myself with my homemade sandalwood deordorant — but no that was the week before, I had forgtten to do that on this day, wanting to get back home as quickly as I could as the many crises in my family were proliferating and seeming to me to be spiralling out of control.

But I felt after running all that distance I was back in control of my paltry, dessicated British life–I had had two lives before this: in India till I was 3, and in Amerikkka till I was 43, my third incarnation was now here in late fascist Britain for the past 15 years and I will have had a fourth intersectionally communist life before I die. I felt after my run that my ‘self-improvement’ activity was practical and not inert. And then the specific practico-inert in which British late fascism swims as if a fish in water hit me and left me momentarily speechless, bereft of coordinates and orientation (cf Sara Ahmed’s critical work on orientation in Queer Phenomenology). In I went to the gym, a semi-public, semi-private site of not so hidden ‘violence, darkness, and magic’ (see the quote from Banaji below). A white 50-something skinhead started following me, but I didn’t clock him. I was intent on listening to Jairus Banaji’s essay in A Marxist Mosaic, the one on “Dialectic and History: Work, Alienation, Classes and the State in Sartre’s Critique of Dialectical Reason” (185-238).

Walthamstow Central tube station – ceramic tiles by Mike Quinn is licensed under CC-BY-SA 2.0

Then after a while I sensed him, started to mark his gaze from the corner of my eye, he was glaring at me. It’s something both utterly impossible and totally prosaic, I don’t know how to put it, words fail me every time — the stare of white people in Britain, but this too was something different. There was a hot hatred coming from his eyes, which is usually submerged out on the streets of Walthamstow, E17 becoming visibly queer, white Walthamstow, home to the new Soho Theatre colony in northeast London and all the hipsters who can fit in these squeezed slivers of flats and terraced housing, neighbourhoods that were until recently home to Pakistani and Caribbean immigrant communities. No, this was the glare of white supremacist hatred, and I felt my body starting to burn from it. But naively I thought, oh this skinhead must just really be irritated a brown man is on his machine, so I got off of it–it didn’t occur to me that it was I that was contaminating his machine. I went to the next machine for grinding working class bones into passivity, hoping his glare would subside. He kept staring at me, eyes vomiting hateful rage. He came over to me, looked at the machine I had been on, looked at me, took a threatening step toward me, and spat out, “Filthy.”

The corporate gym responded to my complaint by denying race had anything to do with it, and…wait for it . . . raising my monthly dues! After all, its all about money in racial capital, anyway, so its clarifying.

What is the genealogy of this interpellation? How are we relating this to the practico-inert as Banaji takes this concept up from Sartre’s Critique of Dialectical Reason, Vol. 1? I will quote long passages to try to understand my situation, our–who? surely you don’t mean … no–so I’ll just limit it to my (nonetheless collective) standpoint: How do I as an intersectionally complex and queerly affirmative and undeniably brown, experimentally open marxist make sense of Britain’s late fascism, of this one ‘violent’ incident in the merry borough of Waltham Forest? Let’s turn to Banaji.

A Marxist Mosaic is an extraordinary collection of essays spanning over 40 years of radical commitment to revolutionary marxism and the ad hominen critique of racial capital (not his term, but he diagrammed its decisive contours avant la lettre) and settler colonialism (a term he does use, which makes me wonder why recent turns to ‘colonial capitalism’ don’t engage his work more centrally). Here’s an excellent passage on the practico-inertia of racial capitalist techno-human assemblages and labour exploitation and fascist and settler colonial seriality in Sartre and beyond:

This dimension of passivity, of the absorption of human action by the inertia of materiality, is the sphere of man’s domination by worked matter, or of his domination by himself as matter. ‘In surpassing the given material conditions man objectifies himself in matter through work: that means he loses himself so that the human thing comes into being’ [Sartre 1960, p. 238; Sartre 1976, p. 170]. Loses himself – his praxis becomes absorbed in passive and inert syntheses of innumerable other actions, and his finality (his ends) reappears as counterfinality (as a negation of his ends). The Chinese peasant household that cuts wood from the surrounding forests – this is a living organic action motivated by need – creates an absence of forests and eventually, through this absence of forests, massive periodic flooding and famines. ‘Worked matter’, materiality that absorbs and passivises human action, ‘reflects our activity back to us as inertia and our inertia as our activity’. It is this dimension of passivised action, of worked matter as the alienated (counterfinal) objectification of praxis that Sartre calls the practico-inert. The practico-inert, this ‘site of violence, darkness and magic’, of an inverted praxis, is the specifically non-dialectical moment of the Critique. Sartre explores this level of historical intelligibility, praxis as inertia, and the experience of this inertia as a praxis-without-authorship, as necessity, with the example, taken from Braudel’s major study, of the circulation of precious metals in the Mediterranean world of the Renaissance. To start with, there is no being, no materiality or matter devoid of human significance – at least not within the field of human experience. ‘At any given historical time, things are human to the very degree that men are things’. Matter as the inert and passive support of human action, as an inertia that retains its meanings, refers us to those very projects, to human action, as dialectically fundamental. In fact, there could be no experience of alienation (of domination by worked matter) if man were not basically action. If he were pure materiality, neither action nor alienation would be conceivable. ‘Slavery is possible only because there is freedom’. Only two choices are possible at this level. Either man is ontologically other than himself and one then elaborates a philosophy founded on a hatred of man. Or man is himself, he is the active source of this destiny which confronts him as his future. And if man were pure being, the only time conceivable would be the time of degradation, a dialectic moving in reverse from the complex to the simple, in short, involution and dissolution would then replace evolution. Thus, at the start of Spain’s ineluctable decadence and crisis, there lies human action. The regime of Philip ii accumulates the precious metals. That is, organ- ises their extraction, transport, melting and minting into coins. But there is no human action that does not crystallise its meanings in matter, and no matter that does not condition human action through the passive unity of its prefab- ricated meanings. Thus, ‘the Spanish government accumulates gold but there is a flight of gold’. If the accumulation of gold is founded on a type of human mediation defined by a common, deliberate praxis that unifies certain men in a single enterprise aimed at a single objective, then this flight of gold implies another form of human mediation which Sartre will call ‘serial’. (197-98)

The gym is the contemporary theatre of the practico-inert, branded spaces flaunting the contemporary dimensions of passivised action, of worked matter (the workers body worked out, worked on, worked over, pacified) as ‘the alienated (counterfinal) objectification of praxis that Sartre calls the practico-inert’ where our inertia is reflected back to us as our ‘activity’. Even as Banaji notes that the practico-inert is the non-dialectical moment in Sartre’s critique, I believe this analysis remains too dialectical in both Sartre and Banaji and the molecular intensities territorialized in this space, in these serialities (cf Guattari on serialities), where difference does not go all the way up to contradictory difference, and the race racing of its becomings remain diffuse, opaque, and inchoate at the level of intensity–these molecularities are just as important. The representational closure of the dialectic is evident here and that is precisely why “only two choices are possible at this level.” This is, rather, a space of controlled multiplicities, a control through modulation and the dividual, and an unending tracking of techno-human movement. More, what of the anthropocentrism that Banaji inherits from Sartre? “Matter as the inert and passive support of human action, as an inertia that retains its meanings, refers us to those very projects, to human action, as dialectically fundamental.” What if matter, the matter of and in the gym, is both active and inert, passive and active, moving in serialities along gradients of belonging? In short, how do we comprehend without neutralising the force, sense, and value of the white supremacist illocutionary act? One day when I recover my energy levels and something like equanimity I will return to this post and keep writing on racism, fascism, and seriality. I end this iteration with another quote from Banaji.

This conception enables us to distinguish serial forms of behaviour of a purely passive variety and controlled serial actions. Take the following example. We have seen how a practico-inert object (e.g. gold, the universal machine) can produce its own ‘idea’ (gold creates the idea that its accumulation is an expansion of wealth; the universal machine creates its own idea in the syn- dicalism of the craft worker). To the extent that this inert object becomes the common-being-outside-self of a series, the idea which that object creates of itself becomes as such the unity of the series. ‘It is in this way that colonial- ism, as a material system in the practico-inert field of colonisation, or, if you like, as the common interest of the settlers, produces its own Idea in the very course of development’. If colonialism defines the exploited in the colonies ‘in terms of their essence (that is, as exploitable sub specie aeternitatis), that is because it cannot afford the slightest change in their condition without inviting self-destruction. Colonialism defines the exploited masses as eternal because it constitutes itself as the eternity of exploitation. To the extent that this inert sentence passed on the colonized becomes, in its ideological form, the serial unity of the settlers, in other words, their bond of alterity, it is the Idea as Other or the Other as Idea. It remains therefore an Idea of stone, but its force derives from its absence everywhere (ubiquité d’absence). In this form of otherness, it becomes racism. The peculiarity of racism is that one is not dealing in its case with a system of thoughts (pensées) which are false or malignant. Racism is in no sense a thought. Its very formulation is impossible … In reality, racism is the colonial interest lived as a bond between all the settlers in the colony through the serial flight of alterity’.203 ‘In this specific case, the serial unity of the settlers comes to them from the Absolute Other who is the colonised, and produces an image of the colonized themselves as an active grouping … (234)

But then it would be to Hegel that we must return to fully comprehend fascism today. Not the Master-Slave dialectic of the Phenomenology of Spirit (tropologically a refrain in Hegel: the relation of domination), but to the dance of dialectical attraction and repulsion in the one and the many ones in the Greater Logic (1817).2 We will quote long sections, doing a close reading . . .

c. repulsion and attraction a. Exclusion of the one: The many ones are each a being; their existence or their reference to one another is a non-reference, it is external to them: the abstract void. But they themselves are now this negative reference to themselves as to existent others: the demonstrated contradiction, the infinity posited in the immediacy of being. With this, repulsion now finds immediately before it that which is repelled by it. In this determination, it is an excluding; the one repels from itself only the many not generated by it, the ones not posited by it. This repelling is mutual or from all sides – relative, limited by the being of the ones. Plurality is not at first posited otherness; limit is only the void, only that in which the ones are not. But in the limit they also are; they are in the void, or their repulsion is their common connecting reference. This mutual repulsion is the posited existence of the many ones; it is not their being-for-itself, in accordance with which they would be distinguished as many only in a third, but is rather their own distinguishing which preserves them. – They mutually negate themselves, posit one another as being only for-one. But at the same time they negate this being only for one just as much; they repel the ideality that they have and are. – So the moments which in ideality are absolutely united come apart. In its being for- itself, the one is also for-one; but this one, for which it is, is itself; its distinguishing from itself is immediately sublated. But in the plurality the distinguished one has a being; the being-for-one as has been determined in exclusion is therefore a being-for-other. Each thus comes to be repelled by an other, is sublated and made into a one which is not for itself but for-one, and an other one at that. The being-for-itself of the many ones thus shows itself to be their self-preservation through the mediation of their mutual repulsion in which they sublated themselves reciprocally and posit the others as mere being-for- another. But the self-preservation consists at the same time in repelling this ideality and positing the ones as not being for-an-other. This self-preservation of the ones through their negative reference to one another is, however, rather their dissolution. (2010: 138)

  • Repulsion/attraction, fort/da, repetition/compulsion. And abstraction [awryaside: who will write the book of the career of this Idea — Abstraction — in Hegel? Does Toscano’s work not show a deep appreciation of this question Abstraction? By not writing a book on Hegel, did Deleuze already always write the book of Abstraction, as in Abstract Diagrams, more of Felix’s contribution anyway . . . ? [more awryasides: Why does homosexuality haunt the scene/shein/spectacle of fascism? What is the specific force and sense of that scene in “One Battle [of Algiers] After Another” in which the fascist Sean Penn character Steven J. Lockjaw, who is about to have his ‘mongrel’ [filthy, impure, unclean] daughter killed, insists/pleads with her “I am not a homosexual!” Why is fascism always in the closet, even, or especially when it’s openly queer, as in queer zionism?
  • Hegel: he is Certain of the motion of his dialectic, a kind of transcalar rhythmic movement (which he denies and cancels out, or attempts to in the stranglehold of negations of the negation) . . . we merge critically with this, through this rhythmic dialectical movement. Infinite immediacy negated mutually. And of course we are back in the jouer of mediation, mediation mediating in mutual repulsion of monadic infinite immediacies? What is the relation of mediation to abstraction in Hegel, how does it relate to the histories of fascism, anti-semitism, rent, migration, wage-labour, imperialism and zionism, resonating beyond the work of Adorno and Postone? But there is another line of flight here, the non-linear story of the becoming being for an/other . . .

b. The one one of attraction: Repulsion is the fragmentation of the one, first into the many of which it is the negative relating, since they presuppose each other as each existent; it is only the ought of ideality; this ideality will, however, be realized in attraction. Repulsion passes over into attraction, the many ones into one one. Both, repulsion and attraction, are at first distinguished from each other, repulsion as the reality of the ones, attraction as their posited ideality. Attraction refers to repulsion by having it for a presupposition. Repulsion delivers the material for attraction. If there were no ones, there would be nothing to attract; the representation of continuing attraction, of the consumption of the ones, presupposes an equally continuing generation of the ones; the sense representation of spatial attraction gives continuity to the flow of ones to be attracted; to replace the atoms that vanish at the point of attraction, another multitude comes forth from the void, infinitely if one so wishes. If attraction were represented as accomplished, that is, the many as brought to the point of the one one, the result would be just an inert one, no longer any attraction. The ideality immediately present in attraction still also has in it the determination of the negation of itself, the many ones to which it refers; attraction is inseparable from repulsion. To attract pertains at first in equal measure to each of the many ones as immediately present; none has advantage over an other; what would result then is an equilibrium in the attraction, or more precisely, an equilibrium in the attraction and the repulsion themselves, and an inert state of rest without any ideality present there. But there can be no question here of any such immediately present one taking precedence over another, for this would presuppose a determinate distinction between them; attraction is rather the positing of the given lack of distinction among the ones. Attraction is itself the positing in the first place of a one distinct from other ones; these are only the immediate ones that are to preserve themselves through repulsion; through their posited negation, however, what proceeds is the one of attraction which is therefore determined as the mediated one, the one posited as one. The first ones, as immediate, do not in their ideality return into themselves, but have this ideality each in another. The one one is, however, ideality that has been realized, posited in the one; it attracts through the mediation of repulsion; it contains in itself this mediation as its determination. It thus does not swallow the attracted ones within it as into one point, that is, does not sublate them abstractly. (2010: 141; italics mine)

He called me filthy, and took a step toward me, like ‘he wanted a piece of me’ as they say in Bobby Deniro films. It was cinematic, yes even filthily romantic in an tie-me-up, tie-me-down kind of way, but anyways let’s go back to Hegel.

Remark
Driven to the extreme of the one as being-for-itself, self-subsistence is an
abstract, formal self-subsistence that destroys itself. It is the ultimate, most
stubborn error, one which takes itself as the ultimate truth, whether it
assumes the more concrete form of abstract freedom, of pure “I,” and
further still of evil. It is the freedom which so misconceives itself as to
place its essence in this abstraction, and, in thus shutting itself up within
itself, flatters itself that it attains itself in all purity. This self-subsistence, to
determine it further, is the error of considering its own essence negatively
and of relating itself to it negatively. It is thus a negative relating to itself
which, while wanting to gain its own being, destroys it – and this, his
doing, is only the manifestation of the nullity of the doing
[ouch]. Reconciliation
is the recognition that that towards which the negative relating is directed
is rather its essence, and this is only in the desisting from the negativity of
its being-for-itself rather than in holding fast to it.

It is an ancient proposition that the one is many and especially that the
many is one. It should again be observed in this connection that, as expressed
in propositions, the truth of the one and the many appears in inadequate
form; such a truth is to be grasped and expressed only as a becoming, as a
process, a repulsion and attraction – not as being, in the way the latter is
posited in a proposition as inert unity. Earlier mention was made recalling
Plato’s dialectic in the Parmenides on the derivation of the many from
the one, specifically from the proposition: the one is.
It is the internal
dialectic of the concept that has been expounded; it is easiest to grasp the
dialectic of the proposition, that the many is one, as external reflection;
and, inasmuch as the subject matter also, the many, is a mutual externality,
reflection may indeed be external here. This comparison of the many with
one another immediately shows that each is absolutely determined just as
any other; each is a one, each a one of many; each is by excluding the
others
– so that they are absolutely the same; absolutely one determination
is present. This is a matter of fact, and all that needs to be done is simply to
grasp the fact. If in its stubbornness the understanding refuses to do it, it is
only because it also has distinction in mind, and rightly so; but distinction
is not left out because of that fact, as surely as the fact is no less there despite
distinction. One could, as it were, reassure the understanding concerning
this simple grasp of the fact of unity that distinction will also come in
again
. Repulsion is the fragmentation of the one, first into the many of which it
is the negative relating, since they presuppose each other as each existent;
it is only the ought of ideality; this ideality will, however, be realized in
attraction.
Repulsion passes over into attraction, the many ones into one
one. Both, repulsion and attraction, are at first distinguished from each
other, repulsion as the reality of the ones, attraction as their posited ideality.
Attraction refers to repulsion by having it for a presupposition. Repulsion
delivers the material for attraction
. If there were no ones, there would
be nothing to attract; the representation of continuing attraction, of the
consumption of the ones, presupposes an equally continuing generation
of the ones; the sense representation of spatial attraction gives continuity
to the flow of ones to be attracted
; to replace the atoms that vanish at the
point of attraction, another multitude comes forth from the void, infinitely
if one so wishes. If attraction were represented as accomplished, that is,
the many as brought to the point of the one one, the result would be just
an inert one, no longer any attraction
. The ideality immediately present in
attraction still also has in it the determination of the negation of itself, the
many ones to which it refers; attraction is inseparable from repulsion. (Hegel, 2010: 140-41)

I consider these remarkable passages from the Logic. If it can be said that a certain fold in the work of Denise Ferreira da Silva includes an immanent critique of the Hegelian logic of violence (eg Master/Slave dialectic) as a critique of anti-Blackness and colonialities of racialized power and racial capital (this might be a good moment to go back to da Silva's essay on Difference without Separability, return to this) -- 

If it can be said that Frederic Jameson’s long oeuvre is if nothing else a kind of dystopian speculative fictional riff on Hegel after Marx and Adorno and Spivak and Hall — but which Hegel is that in Jameson? It will take many years and a few more PhD dissertations to pick that question apart–Well it is enough for me in thinking through the marxist, anti-colonial, and queer phenomenology of the interpellation of ‘filfthy’ that I stay with the trouble of this dialectic of attraction and repulsion in the one/many. This never stops being about the constitution of fascist whiteness in and as the sovereign subject of (cis heteromale) mastery — but why say that in the course of writing against what happened — but I am also within it in some uncomfortable ways?

I think one of the most important political lessons I learned in my reading of Spivak’s early work was the persistent critique of the complicities sutured into the (discursive, linguistic, economic, social, and political [–but what is affective in Spivak?]) processes of the Self-consolidating Other. The colonial ambivalence (Bhabha) of societies structured in racial dominance (Hall) require the violent oscillations of attraction/repulsion in all modes of social domination (Young, Stoler, McClintock), in all forms of its on going originary accumulation (Harvey, Cabral, Fanon, Marx), which in the colonial context is not hidden as we see in Palestine today.

The passage above is remarkable in the Shein (appearance) of its simplicity: “each is by excluding the others.” All the others it seems thereby become ‘absolutely the same; absolutely one determination’. And remember: ‘This is a matter of fact, and all that needs to be done is simply to grasp the fact.’ As if. But what of our ‘poor’ relation — the Understanding — which is mired in a kind of barbarity has to be cojoled to think correctly, Caliban like.

Repulsion, thus, is the fragmentation of the one, and this goes some way in clarifying the unconscious cathexis that is riven into repulsion . . . In this economy of violence, we are also witnesses to a theatre of (im)mediation:

To attract pertains at first in equal measure to each of the many ones as immediately present; none has advantage over an other; what would result then is an equilibrium in the attraction, or more precisely, an equilibrium in the attraction and the repulsion themselves, and an inert state of rest without any ideality present there. But there can be no question here of any such immediately present one taking precedence over another, for this would presuppose a determinate distinction between them; attraction is rather the positing of the given lack of distinction among the ones. Attraction is itself the positing in the first place of a one distinct from other ones; these are only the immediate ones that are to preserve themselves through repulsion; through their posited negation, however, what proceeds is the one of attraction which is therefore determined as the mediated one, the one posited as one. The first ones, as immediate, do not in their ideality return into themselves, but have this ideality each in another...The one one is, however, ideality that has been realized, posited in the one; it attracts through the mediation of repulsion; it contains in itself this mediation as its determination. It thus does not swallow the attracted ones within it as into one point, that is, does not sublate them abstractly. Since it contains repulsion in its determination, the latter equally preserves the ones as many within it; by its attracting, it musters, so to speak, something before it, gains an area or a filling. Thus there is in it the unity of repulsion and attraction in general. ... (Hegel 2010: 141-42)

  1. See Guattari, F. The Machinic Unconscious. ↩︎
  2. Hegel, G.W.F., 2010. The science of logic. Cambridge University Press. ↩︎