We will have danced through a series of seminars on what I won’t have called “Revolutionary Speculative Fiction”, in which the sleep of western reason gives birth to monsters composed of technoperceptual assemblages that strike the senses with the full force of monstrosity. What, first, do we mean here by speculative (linked to fabulation and the powers of the false–cf Deleuze)? And what of Utopian Science Fiction? In which senses is science fiction as a kind of speculative fiction an extended discourse on the monster, monstrous utopias, affects, and ontologies, and a discursive practice of monstrosity? But then again, maybe always to an extent (the nth degree?) all ‘definitions serve to be destroyed’? (I will return to Isadora Neves Marques’ e-flux article below)
With the publication and reception of late comrade Marina Vishmidt’s work on speculation as a mode of production (to which we will return in a later post) the concept of speculation has received a new burst of political scrutiny. When we dream together in a utopian, (non)prefigurative vein, what is it we are doing after all other than in a certain sense slipping out from time’s hinged joint, becoming untimely, acting counter to our time, and let us hope dreaming for the benefit of a time to come, of a ‘to the nth power’ affirmation of a multiplicity of indigenous knowledges that can be made to cannibalise the western episteme, as Derrida, Deleuze, Viveiros de Castro, Strathern, Ingold, Stengers suggest, to eat the master from the inside, through an immanent, ad hominen critique of the coloniality of capitalist power — the inveterate white mythologies in the service of profit for profit’s sake — at work in all the disciplines associated with our anthropocene–and in all academic pieties to a prefigurative politics emerging in a speculating temporality (without going into an elaborate etymologism-detournement of this word with links to the specular/um (Irigiray’s Other woman), spectacle (Debord, Wark), speculative philosophy as Hegel’s master-slave becomes Levi-Strauss’ kinship, as the concept of kinship is. . . itself . . . cannibalised immanently . . . as Viveiros de Castro has shown us how to do with French philosophy and French anthropology of Amerindian peoples . . . but does he–despite his at times hilarious and at times sharply polemical and at times astoundingly inventive discourse–render ‘Amerindian thought’ yet another anthropological fetish-artefact?).
But let’s return to the Speculative in Speculative Fiction. Speculation is a kind of experimentation with the power of abstraction, to affirm the capacity of abstraction to the nth power, which if we subtract the phenomenological (im)pieties of the flesh that can sometime surround speculative philosophy, miring it in a supposed science of the consciousness of sensual experience, can maybe leave us with a smooth spacetime of pure potentiality of abstraction? As an aside, we note that the role potentiality, or the virtual plays today in for instance business and management discourses of ‘oragnising’ and ‘organisation’ in process-based models of organisational behaviour or strategy and the new new institutionalism–Chia, Weick, Sutcliffe, Herne, but also the neoliberals that Foucault genealogises in his late 70’s lectures–they too had, if only in an Aristotelian sort of way at times, a conception of the virtual in economic rationality. But we are not here to speculate on potentiality or the virtual, we are writing about the practice of speculation in speculative fiction. I am reading Colson Whitehead’s Zone One: A Novel. The narrative voice, I must say irritated me a bit at the outset, but then I got a different sense of their ‘perspective’ as I got further on; but the speculation in the novel is not about science or technology–so far there is nothing particularly magical or remarkable about the almost probabilistic post apocalyptic zombie world. I will report back as I have come to be intrigued by becoming a ghostly companion to a civilian battalion of zombie killers liberating the toxic grid that is Manhattan. . . .
Speaking of liberation from toxic grids: The Blaft Book of Anti-Caste SF is excellent, and I’m looking forward to engaging with the speculative stories in classroom discussions.
But as another aside, or better, fold … on speculation … what happens when speculation becomes embodied dehabituation? Manning and Massumi help us think this other heading of speculation:
“The habit of entering into a process brings with it the promise that a process engaging with the same conditions twice can generate an event that looks like the event that it generated the first time. But what Brian is saying is that if you take this process seriously, and attend to how it evolves in each of its phases, you will find that no event can be mapped in advance. The event takes us with it and the outcome is always experienced in retrospect: ah! that’s what it was! But instead of saying ‘that’s what it was!’ we have the habit of taking the past and imposing it on the future, quietly exclaiming ‘that’s what it will be!’ Immediation tries to challenge that habit. What we have found in our collective SenseLab [I’ve been; they’re great] network as we work through the relationship between philosophy, art and activism is that techniques have to be generated in the event, each occasion anew, because if they are not, they simply don’t work. That’s the pragmatic side or as we call it the speculative pragmatic side. The event generates its own forms of speculation and forms of pragmatism, and you have to be in the event to compose with them. This is a relational task at the level of the field itself. If you think of yourself as the subject of the event, you’ll fail simply because you will have taken yourself out of all of those complex relational tendencies of the event to generate its own potential. What is at stake here is understanding not the agency of the subject, but the agencement of the event in its speculatively pragmatic unfolding. This is a word that is impossible to translate. The best that anyone’s come up with is ‘assemblage’, but that’s misleading. Agencement connotes a doing doing itself. You have to understand the event itself as agency-ing.” (Erin Manning in Conversation with Massumi, in the Politics of Affect, pg. 157, emphasis added)
We will return to the politics of im/mediation and what decolonial, Black radical, postcolonial, anti-imperialist, and revolutionary Marxist and anarchist refusals of im/mediation dialectics can offer radical politics in situations in which ‘techniques have to be generated in the event.’ What should be composed in the speculative as phase shifting beyond the unending experimentations with the immediating affects of the untimely is I believe a mode of revolutionary becoming of a people; a people to come will have displaced the reifications and im/mediations of racial capital with a kind of people’s ‘science’ (with a little minority-becoming ‘s’), a jugaad science, a hacking ecology of social reproduction and economic production…
… or perhaps less of a displacement than an enfolding and entanglement of scientific institutions (organised force of norms and scripts for behaviour) with materio-spiritual processes of speculating on timespaces yet to come, monstrous speculations, monstrous fabulations. Speculative fiction undoes the narrative-myth-making form of representation tied to the realist novel of development, the bildingroman. But then why do we still need the word ‘fiction’ in science fiction?
Well, yes, then, to speculate as a mode of prefigurative realism, a superior transcendental empiricism for a revolutionary becoming of the future. It will not have been branded, yet, yet, et. As a techno-pedagogical mode of the practice of emancipation, revolutionary speculating in fiction, dance, curation, writing, creation, continuing, caring, repairing, resisting, and loving in the face of the grinding value form of colonial, caste, racial capitalism — .
Is science fiction a ‘people’s science’? Problematising ‘science’ in speculative/science fiction, Marques writes —
“To dismantle preconceived ideas about science fiction, and consequently about both science and fiction, Dillon breaks down the distinction between science, magic, and storytelling. She describes her process as “taking the fiction out of science fiction.” What does this mean? Let’s try the reverse: it means taking the “science” in science fiction not merely as a noun adjunct, as in fiction about science, but more seriously as stories that fundamentally reimagine what science is.”
Agreed. Drawing on Viveiros de Castro’s perspectivism and multi-naturalism, Marques argues that stories that are seen as fantastical tales—and are thereby ‘relegated to the minor genres of paranormal narratives and ghost stories’—for those acquainted with the cosmology of indigenous lifeworlds “it is reality pure and simple. Similarly, it is for this reason that, as I’ve insisted elsewhere—against the grain of most film critics—the films of Thai director Apichatpong Weerasethakul are not surrealist or fantastical. Rather, they offer a sociology of humans, ghosts, spirits, and animal-people—a realism closer to documentary. Apichatpong’s films, like Haig-Brown’s, are not science fiction, or fiction, at all, but scientific tales” (Marques). She continues to note the revolutionary or escapist binary in science fiction; drawing on the critical and affirmative resources of Dillon’s Indigenous Futurism (cf Dillon, G.L., 2016. Introduction: Indigenous futurisms, Bimaashi Biidaas mose, flying and walking towards you. Extrapolation, 57(1-2), pp.1-6) she considers the nonlinearities involved in science fiction not only as an artistic genre representative of nineteenth-century colonial imperialism (Rieder, Colonialism and the Emergence of Science Fiction, Wesleyan University Press, 2008) but in a historical twist that we should see “science fiction was both an expression and an affirmation—a naturalization—of a particular cosmology, a cosmology that attributed to technology the role of dominion over the environment, subsuming all relations to the necessity of extractivism, both human and environmental, by modern imperialisms, whether market capitalist or planned socialist. Science fiction is not a straightforward tool for reflecting the present, much less for predicting the future. Rather, it is a genre that arose from a specific understanding of modernity’s nature-culture divide. And yet, science fiction has also, always, strived to escape or corrupt this divide—hence its revolutionary, or its pure-and-simple escapist, appeal.” Marques concludes thus:
“Counterintuitively, then, science fiction might be more about nature than technology—a reflection on the expectations that constitute what is deemed natural and how this naturalization (of bodies, of ecosystems, of planets) might be speculatively disturbed. The multipolarity of science is the fiction of contemporary science fiction. And this is why I, as a reader and a fan, continue to see it as so speculative and future-oriented. Utopian even. On the matter of definitions then, better to follow the advice of the old, renowned science fiction critic Darko Suvin and say that science fiction does not begin anywhere as such, “for its ‘pre-history’ is one of fundamental impurity.” Let it continue forever impure.”
Here’s to the revolutionary impurity of speculative fiction!
The seminar series aims to synthesise revolutionary praxis, peoples’s sciences and cosmologies, and nomadic and jugaad speculations on the terrain of morphogenesis in different kinds of fiction. To date, the series is called “Revolutionary Speculative Fiction” in acknowledgement of the grimly utopic, negative dialectical, Ballardian dystopias found in the oeuvre of Frederic Jameson. The illuminating and consistent engagement throughout his work with the Frankfurt School, Adorno in particular, and of the dual problem of science fiction as genre and utopia — all through the political telos of the overthrow of racial capital (not his term!). I am just finishing re-reading Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism, after not having read it for over twenty years. I admit to being quite rusty now with the old debates and controversies that seem to animate some of the pages of that book–De Man, in particular, the Nazi collaborating nephew of a famous European socialist, Derrida’s deconstructive dervishes, the charge of ‘linguisticism’ (again not Jameson’s term). But for me what is of lasting significance in and throughout Jameson’s work is this unrelenting marxist (with a small m?) speculation on the conditions of possibility of utopic thought and practice. I feel my insistence on the politically prefigurative potential of revolutionary becoming (cf Rai 2019) to be in resonance with Jameson’s speculations on utopia. But let’s not get behind ourselves, let us with a sidelong nod to Derrida and Butler stay present and intentional: we are speaking here of Jameson’s repurposing of Marxism for a science fiction criticism of the revolutionary imaginary under late capitalism. Let’s recall some important passages from the Postmodernism text(s).
“The initial approach to this particular “great transformation” — the displacement of time, the spatialization of the temporal — often registers its novelties by way of a sense of loss. [ASR: This sense of loss, this affect of loss without recourse or recuperation, inhabits the different genres of sceience fiction; Jameson suggests that this sense is a postmodern mode of totalising.] Indeed, it seems just possible that the pathos of entropy in Ballard may be just that: the affect released by the minute, and not unenthusiastic, exploration of this whole new world of spatiality, and the sharp pang of the death of the modern that accompanies it. At any rate, from this nostalgic and regressive perspective — that of the older modern and its temporalities — what is mourned is the memory of deep memory; what is enacted is a nostalgia for nostalgia, for the grand older extinct questions of origin and telos, of deep time and the Freudian Unconscious (dispatched by Foucault at one blow in the History of Sexuality), for the dialectic also, as well as all the monumental forms left high and dry by the ebb tide of the modern moment, forms whose Absolutes are no longer audible to us, illegible hieroglyphs of the demiurgic within the technocratic world. We need a detour through the modern, then, in order to grasp what is historically original in the postmodern and its spatialisms. Indeed, such a history lesson is the best cure for nostalgic pathos, minimally teaching us, by way of Necessity, that the way back to the modern is sealed for good. Presupposed in what follows, of course, is a correlation between the transition from the modern to the postmodern, and that economic or systemic transformation of an older monopoly capitalism (the so-called moment of imperialism) into its new multinational and hightech mutation. Increasingly spatial features of a new type can be derived from such economic accounts, but any concrete account of the new spatial aesthetic and its existential life world demands some intermediary steps, or what the dialectic used to call mediations.” (Jameson, Postmodernism)
Why did the dialectic used to call it ‘mediations’, these intermediary steps? Is indeed the dialectic and its mediations always already dead in Jameson, or rather is the dialectic always already entombed, reified in a European will to death-as-self/other-mastery, its white authenticity forever disavowed (Heidegger, Adorno, Derrida, Foucault, Jameson, Fisher)? What are the dialectic’s strange adventures in the intergalactic smashing of matter and anti-matter that is staged in Jameson’s utopic science fiction(s), and which are his corrective mythologies, tied to a story he maybe wrongly attributed to Marx, and were instead another kind of collective enunciation (Erin Manning marks that for Fred Moten writing is a collective act)? A universal army for the production of new theoretical discourse within and against conceptual reification? Remember that for Jameson, Adorno indexes the persistence of the (negative) dialectic.
When does Marxism become Science Fiction in Jameson? It’s about temporality in a historically specific mode of production, of course! History is what hurts, he had written long ago. He writes: “The future itself — Dick’s 1997 — is not, however, centrally significant as a representation or an anticipation; it is the narrative means to a very different end, namely the brutal transformation of a realistic representation of the present, of Eisenhower America and the 1950s small town, into a memory and a reconstruction. Reification is here indeed built into the novel itself and, as it were, defused and recuperated as a form of praxis: the fifties is a thing, but a thing that we can build, just as the science fiction writer builds his own small-scale model. At that point, then, reification ceases to be a baleful and alienating process, a noxious side-effect of our mode of production, if not, indeed, its fundamental dynamic, and is rather transferred to the side of human energies and human possibilities. (The reappropriation has, of course, a good deal to do with the specificity of Dick’s own themes and ideology — in particular, the nostalgia about the past and the “petit bourgeois” valorization of small craftsmanship, as well as small business and collecting.)” (Jameson, Postmodernism) This is a lovely passage on Dick; it brings out a bit what Jameson at this point in his thinking understands by the term representation. Jamesonian totality is what kind of multiplicity?
Future anterior: “One would want, in short, to stress the conditions of possibility of such a form — and of its emergence and eclipse — less in the existential experience of history of people at this or that historical moment than rather in the very structure of their socioeconomic system, in its relative opacity or transparency, and the access its mechanisms provide to some greater cognitive as well as existential contact with the thing itself. This is the context in which it seems interesting to explore the hypothesis that science fiction as a genre entertains a dialectical and structural relationship with the historical novel — a relationship of kinship and inversion all at once, of opposition and homology (just as comedy and tragedy have often been supposed to do, or lyric and epic, or satire and Utopia, as Robert C. Elliott analyzed them). But time itself plays a crucial role in this generic opposition, which is also something of an evolutionary compensation. For if the historical novel “corresponded” to the emergence of historicity, of a sense of history in its strong modern post-eighteenth-century sense, science fiction equally corresponds to the waning or the blockage of that historicity, and, particularly in our own time (in the postmodern era), to its crisis and paralysis, its enfeeblement and repression. Only by means of a violent formal and narrative dislocation could a narrative apparatus come into being capable of restoring life and feeling to this only intermittently functioning organ that is our capacity to organize and live time historically. Nor should it be thought overhastily that the two forms are symmetrical on the grounds that the historical novel stages the past and science fiction the future…. Historicity is, in fact, neither a representation of the past nor a representation of the future (although its various forms use such representations): it can first and foremost be defined as a perception of the present as history; that is, as a relationship to the present which somehow defamiliarizes it and allows us that distance from immediacy which is at length characterized as a historical perspective. It is appropriate, in other words, also to insist on the historicality of the operation itself, which is our way of conceiving of historicity in this particular society and mode of production; appropriate also to observe that what is at stake is essentially a process of reification whereby we draw back from our immersion in the here and now (not yet identified as a “present”) and grasp it as a kind of thing — not merely a “present” but a present that can be dated and called the eighties or the fifties. Our presupposition has been that today this is more difficult to achieve than at the time of Sir Walter Scott, when a contemplation of the past seemed able to renew our sense of our own reading present as the sequel, if not particularly the culmination, of that genetic series. Time Out of Joint, however, offers a very different machine for producing historicity than Sir Walter Scott’s apparatus: what one might in the strong sense call a trope of the future anterior -the estrangement and renewal as history of our own reading present, the fifties, by way of . . . ” (Jameson, Postmodernism).
We will have to come back to some of those quotes above, stay with them, wander in their desolation and refusals. The anti-anti-communist Jameson, the sci-fi author, Jameson. What will we read?
Some ideas (aside from those mentioned above like the Blaft Book of Anti-Caste SF):
Dillon, G. L. (Ed.). (2013). Walking the clouds : an anthology of indigenous science fiction. University of Arizona Press. http://www.gbv.de/dms/sub-hamburg/668230606.pdf
Sartre, J.P. (2004) Critique of Dialectical Reason: Theory of practical ensembles (Vol. 1). Verso.
Fehrle, J., Lieber, M. and Ramirez, J.J., 2024. (De) automating the future: Marxist perspectives on capitalism and technology (Vol. 321). Brill.
Shelly, M. 1817. Frankenstein.
Wells, H.G., 2003. The war of the worlds. Broadview Press.
Milner, A., 2018. Again, dangerous visions: essays in cultural materialism. In Again, Dangerous Visions: Essays in Cultural Materialism. Brill.
Unpayable Debt by Denise Ferreira da Silva
Butler, Octavia E., 2004. Kindred. Beacon Press.